cmdr_flashheart: The downside I see to that is that this thread is so popular that it's the first thing people think of, I believe, when they think quick giveaway;
At the very least, I think people who post in the Ninja Giveaway thread are free to decide what conditions they should have for their post :]
Momo1991: As to gifting, I have the Non-gog gift thread bookmarked (along with about 20 other threads ;-p).
As to "rules", gifters have always been allowed to make up their own rules - not saying this isn't the case. Heck, I sometimes do video ninja to gift a game here. Some gifters ask that whomever wants a game explain why they really, really want to play it. Sometimes - first reply or first PM or first to answer X-question...
Anyway, it's an excellent idea but I forsee it getting lost in a couple of days - that or a few gifters will decide this is how they're doing their ninja giveaways going forward. Dunno...
Like I said, IF someone wants to do it, then they can do it.
I'll re-post a reminder for others who are not here right now, but may want to do it.
Everything has to start somewhere :]
edit: I am logging off for now, will reply later if there's anything :]