Aaron86: Including the JRPGs?
Those aren't RPGs :P
Though sure, why not? I would love to play some of their grid-based tactical games like Final Fantasy Tactics.
MobiusArcher: This is probably going to get me some flack, but I prefer to play FPS games made for consoles with a controller. The gameplay is balanced for the reduced accuracy. The games compensate for the controller by reducing ranges and various other tricks. When using a mouse its nothing but headshots. It feels a bit like cheating, and makes it less fun for me. Battlefield 3 is probably the only recent big budget shooter that isn't made primarily for consoles, so I play pretty much all shooter games with a controller. I also have no issues with consoles myself, so that's what I get my shooters on now. I did just buy Battlefield 3 for PC 4 days ago though. Getting that one on console when you have a gaming PC seems pointless even to me.
I don't think you're wrong really, it makes sense to play games as they were designed. That said I hate analog aiming so much I can't stand to play any game like that. I dislike even using analog sticks for camera control.