It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
avatar
Tarm: What? Yelling? Me?

That's pure nostalgic gold. :)
avatar
RandomJC: oh no, the guy i first responded to you. you've been reasonable.
Ah ok. Confusion cleared. :)
I stopped watching teasers a long time ago... they're just useless, generating hype with a few seconds of - nothing?
Trailers are somewhat useful, since they can help you decide whether you would like to watch a movie or not... but I'm going to see this one anyway, so are you, so what's the matter?

Though, of course, I couldn't resist to see this one and I only have to say: I'm excited.
avatar
RandomJC: oh no, the guy i first responded to you. you've been reasonable.
avatar
Tarm: Ah ok. Confusion cleared. :)
I have no reason to hate on you...yet. *mock evil glare.*
Just watched it and... i don't know. As a teaser i guess it's doing it's job, show a half dozen random scenes with no context that does feel a bit like the Star Wars universe, yet...

What's with the storm troopers? To my understanding they were leftovers from the clone wars, unless more of them were made regularly there shouldn't really be a huge number of them after the empire went down....

Then as mentioned, the laser cross guard because... why? the electronics would be damaged before the laser guarded against anything...



I'd almost rather see Disney do a really really good job of the Claymore Anime as a live action...
avatar
ET3D: Anyway, the problem for me is that after watching some Lego Star Wars: The Yoda Chronicles ... I don't think I'll be able to watch another Star Wars which takes itself seriously.
I totally know what you mean. Pretty much any of the Lego Star Wars videos are a decent parody / gentle poke of the movies/cartoons.
avatar
Tarm: Ah ok. Confusion cleared. :)
avatar
RandomJC: I have no reason to hate on you...yet. *mock evil glare.*
*hides in a game forum*
That was actually pretty good. With this being a teaser trailer and the movie being more than a year away, I was surprised to see some actual live action footage showing a few of the new actors, storm troopers, X-Wings, TIE Fighters and the Millennium Falcon! I didn't think we'd see more than a few still shots, text and logos.
avatar
Sanjuro: Nah,it's pretty justified, the Sith are all about hard training, constant pain, suffering and danger. What better way to show this than to give a Sith a lightsaber with two additional "blades" that serve no other purpose than to cut off the wielder's arm if (s)he's not careful. Remember Darth Maul's "master gave me this to show that he always favoured Dooku over me" double-bladed sword? Well, that's the next step.
avatar
Elmofongo: HAH even then that lightsaber in the trailer is nothing compared to this:

http://a.disquscdn.com/uploads/mediaembed/images/1487/9818/original.jpg
please god no, make it stop :(
avatar
Breja: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OMOVFvcNfvE

There it is. I have to say, it looks... rather bad. If I didn't know it's real, I'd say it's a fake. It looks fake somehow. The ball-droid and the light-broadsword look just silly.
I'll give you the ball droid, but the cross-guard on the lightsaber? The cross-guard of a sword is the part between the hilt and the blade which extends outwards and prevents the other guy from simply sliding the sword down as soon as they lock to cut at your hand or arm, which is exactly what happened to Obi Wan in his first fight with Count Dooku. Also the original trilogy lightsabers had weight to them and acted like broadswords.

I find it mildly amusing a teaser has garnered such a strong reaction when its only goal appears to be to say 'There's a new Starwars movie coming, it will have lightsabers, and stormtroopers.' THAT'S IT. That's all it conveys. And yet people have dissected and criticized every single second. Including the black guy.
Post edited November 29, 2014 by markrichardb
avatar
RandomJC: I have no reason to hate on you...yet. *mock evil glare.*
avatar
Tarm: *hides in a game forum*
You I like.
You I keep.
avatar
Breja: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OMOVFvcNfvE

There it is. I have to say, it looks... rather bad. If I didn't know it's real, I'd say it's a fake. It looks fake somehow. The ball-droid and the light-broadsword look just silly.
avatar
markrichardb: I'll give you the ball droid, but the cross-guard on the lightsaber? The cross-guard of a sword is the part between the hilt and the blade which extends outwards and prevents the other guy from simply sliding the sword down as soon as they lock to cut at your hand or arm, which is exactly what happened to Obi Wan in his first fight with Count Dooku. Also the original trilogy lightsabers had weight to them and acted like broadswords.
I guess it's just that the cross-guard in normal swords was not made of additional blades. And while it might more sensible when you think of lighsaber duel from Episode IV, much slower, more knight-like, it just looks like something to slice your own wrists in all the later duels with all the ninja-jumping around and whirling the lightsabre around.

avatar
markrichardb: I find it mildly amusing a teaser has garnered such a strong reaction when its only goal appears to be to say 'There's a new Starwars movie coming, it will have lightsabers, and stormtroopers.' THAT'S IT. That's all it conveys.
Exactly. And we already know all that. People wanted to ba amazed, awed, and what we got was just mediocre. What little was shown was very unimpressive. I would be more impressed if we got a 30 second teaser with nothing else then a close up of someone constructing a lightsabre, with some well wrtitten narration by Mark Hamill. At least that would be something special. This just looks so generic.

I mean just look at the Dark Knight teaser or the Star Trek teaser. They show basically nothing, but they convey a lot about the movie, and are memorable, unique. The new Star Wars teaser is literally "something (desert), something (ball-droid), something (girl on bike), dark side".
Post edited November 29, 2014 by Breja
That was an interesting trailer, I am glad to see the good ol' Tie Fighters are still around.

That style of Lightsaber looked familiar, I thought I saw it in one of the comics a few years back?
avatar
rtcvb32: What's with the storm troopers? To my understanding they were leftovers from the clone wars, unless more of them were made regularly there shouldn't really be a huge number of them after the empire went down....
Presumably, the Civil War isn't quite wrapped up yet. As to Stormtroopers, they were never clones, but regular recruits. Though, with all the previous expanded canon wiped, there's no telling.
avatar
xxxIndyxxx: The lightsaber is canon and yes it looks like it was made by a noob but that's probably intentional since there aren't really jedi or sith left to teach him or her...
Not hating on the film or anything... As I said: It doesn't look as bad as EP I-III. I just made the "n00b comment" because the lightsaber looks more like a lightningsaber with all that twitching on the edges (lasers don't do that).

And, yes, the CGI looks damn good for CGI. Horrible CGI is one of the main reasons why I hate the the prequels and the original "extended-special-enhanced-Greedo-shots-first" trilogy -.- The ball droid is a bit meh, but the X-Wings look REALLY good.
avatar
xxxIndyxxx: The lightsaber is canon and yes it looks like it was made by a noob but that's probably intentional since there aren't really jedi or sith left to teach him or her...
avatar
real.geizterfahr: Not hating on the film or anything... As I said: It doesn't look as bad as EP I-III. I just made the "n00b comment" because the lightsaber looks more like a lightningsaber with all that twitching on the edges (lasers don't do that).

And, yes, the CGI looks damn good for CGI. Horrible CGI is one of the main reasons why I hate the the prequels and the original "extended-special-enhanced-Greedo-shots-first" trilogy -.- The ball droid is a bit meh, but the X-Wings look REALLY good.
I thought the X-Wing, Falcon, and Tie fighters looked good.