Silent Hills
Admittedly I think that it would have continued the series' tradition of beating a dead horse but at the same time I'm a fan of Kojima's work and am at least curious what he would have done with the license. It probably would not have been a good Silent Hill but it probably would have been a great game.

Freedom Fighters 2
I think it wasn't ever officially announced but some sources suggested that IOI were working on it, although those may have actually been about Kane & Lynch which quite obviously began as a spiritual successor to Freedom Fighters. However, IIRC there was also some report from EA which suggested that they were planning a sequel to Freedom Fighters. It's one of my favourite games of all time so this cancellation really hurt.

Outcast 2: The Lost Paradise
Ages ago there were plans for a sequel on PS2, there are even some screenshots around. I really love the original game, it's a bummer it never got a sequel. But there's still hope, I guess.

Prey 2
Fallout Van Buren
Stalker 2

In response to some of the other suggestions:

Outcast 2: Looked every bit the third person action PS2 game. I didn't see anything that made the original stand out in the screens that were available of it.

They: Again, pretty generic of the platform. Only this time it's a first person corridor shooter with lots of glowing stuff going on. Weapon customisation and the weapons in general looked good and are worth salvaging though.

Dungeon Keeper 3: It would have been great to have a third one, but I'm not aware of there being much work on it at the time of Bullfrog's demise. All I've ever seen is a small teaser video suggesting outside environments.

Alien RPG: Incredibly ropey, even for an early build. The average PS2 game looked a hell of a lot better 8 years beforehand. Obsidian are always hit and miss company and this was looking like a big miss.

Van Buren
Prey 2


I can't believe noone has mentioed those 2 babies:

Arcanum's cancelled sequel (http://www.rpgcodex.net/forums/index.php?threads/arcanum-underworld-ultima-underworld-inspired-pitch-document-for-unmade-arcanum-sequel.104723/)

MEANTIME - goddamnit, dat vaporware, geez Fargo, stop baiting us

The original sequel to Operation Flashpoint before Bohemia Interactive split with Codemasters.

It was meant to have a better environment with vegetation and buildings that would get properly destroyed when you blew them up and other things.

There never was such a cancelled Operation Flashpoint game by Bohemia Interactive. After the split-up Bohemia kept the rights to everything excluding the Operation Flashpoint name, so whatever they actually had ended up in ARMA. The features you cited were just typical over-promising.

Heh.
Molyneux juniors and T. Howard juniors everywhere

In Order of ,,Awww, maaaan." :

(everly link leads to a video showing at least a few facts about the game, at best a demo/prototype)

Baldurs Gate 3 - The Black Hound

Legacy of Kain: The Dark Prophecy

The real Fallout 3: Van Buren

Monkey Island 3 (I like Curse, i just really want to know how Ron Gilberts story would have continued)

Aliens : Crucible

Sam and Max: Freelance Police

Prince of Persia : Assassins (this became Assassins Creed)

Warcraft Adventures: Lord of the Clans

Gotham by Gaslight

Legacy of Kain : Dead Sun

Pirates of the Caribbean: Armada of the Damned

Outcast 2: The Lost Paradise

Whore of the Orient

Dungeon Keeper 3

The "Risen" that was part of the "Gothic" franchise (this is only so low because i like how Risen turned out, at least the first one)

Apart from those, everything Troika Games would have made. Wikipedia lists an Arcanum Sequel, a Vampire Masquerade Bloodlines Sequel and an untitled post-apocalyptic RPG. Im sure at least the first two would have been absolutely awesome, the third one probably too.
Also, whatever Bioware would have made if EA hadn't bought em.

That one is Boyarsky trying to get Fallout rights and having an idea pitched, but Bethesda won him.

Yeah, the Toddler got rights to Fallout and made F3 when we woukd have got an awesome real RPG from Troika

back when i still cared about MMORPGs... VQ 2+. it never got pass beta and will forever be lost in internet time.

Vagabond's Quest browser game info.
everything2.com/title/Vagabond%2527s+Quest

what's left of VQ 2.
www.onlinegamesinn.com/showgame/369/Vagabond's%20Quest%202/

Wait, there was a third ? How does it fare compared to the others ?

Beyond Good and Evil 2.
Starcraft: Ghost.
TimeSplitters 4

RIP.

It's called TimeSplitters: Future Perfect.

IMO it's the best in the series by far.

This is also my biggest pain when it comes to games that I never got to play. It makes it even a bigger loss to know, now, that it was the last time that all of the original cast played their roles.

I think the big mistake they made was trying to use all that "state-of the-art" graphics and modelling. Had they simply used the same engine that was used in 25th Anniversary and Judgment Rites, I'm sure we would have an outstanding trilogy now.

And yes, that trailer video was on Starfleet Academy CD-ROM.


But Leisure Suit Larry: Lust in Space actually got cancelled, and there was some work already done for the game. I think there was some short video clip on Al Lowe's site (or some other place) about that. That's all that remains anymore, as whatever existed went to dumpster when Sierra was finished as a company.

And what's great about Larry 3 was really the beginning.
I actually learned the word "binoculars" from that... :-)


I think he's either refering to the fact that it was written by different people than the first two games, or that the game was a complete departure from the style that the first two games had (so much so that the remakes imitated MI3 style), or a combination of both.
But yes, I think it was never cancelled in any way. It was simply different.
And a remake of that was not even planned, as far as I'm aware of, so it's really a bit out of place here.

Akira (Sega MegaDrive)

Cancelled before release.

It wouldve been so epic at that time.

[url=https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TimeSplitters:_Future_Perfect]Yup, there was[/url]. I liked it more than the second one, but I can't comment on whether it was better than the first one, as I didn't play that one at all.

Heroes of Might and Magic III's Heavenly Forge expansion that was scrapped and became Armageddon's Blade.
[url=http://mightandmagic.wikia.com/wiki/Forge_(town)]http://mightandmagic.wikia.com/wiki/Forge_(town)[/url]