cw8: I'm no modern day console gamer, but is it safe to say this will fail horribly against the PS4? I hope nothing bad happens to PC gaming, the PC gaming drought in 2007-2008 is pretty horrible for me.
cogadh: I don't think it will fail horribly, but I think MS has hurt its standing with the "core gamer" crowd at this point, where Sony has done a lot to raise their standing. I think this cycle is Sony's to lose now. As long as they don't do anything monumentally stupid, they will come out on top, but it won't be a landslide victory.
Frankly, the fact that both Sony and MS went with standard PC architecture for their respective systems might turn out to be a boon for PC gaming. Now when a game is ported, it won't be the usual "crappy console port" with substandard graphics and such, it will be more or less a 1:1 conversion that looks and plays great on all systems. In theory, at least.
It won`t fail, since the sheep cannot go without their `New Shiny`(tm), in modern terms, the newest Call of Duty, Madden, etc.
What will be interesting is to see if M$ `falling on their sword`, harming their profitability and marketshare in order to eradicate used game sales and piracy will be a worthwhile gamble, and if Sony and Nintendo will follow suit. In essence, after M$ does it this gen, Sony and Nintendo have virtually no reason NOT to next gen, and every reason to do so. Should be interesting. By the way, anyone that buys one of these things is fucking clinically insane.
And as always, that is demonstrable, objective fact.