Posted November 14, 2014
yogsloth: There is risk in anything. If I screwed up that cleared list, then yes, we can lose. Are you suggesting an alternate plan that is 100% mathematically certain victory for town? Because I haven't heard it from you yet, and I'm going to be blunt - the doubt you throw out without a better idea rings as very scummy to me.
I clear Robb because he passed the "vanillagate" word test by Darko, and I really don't think that:
a) There are any vanilla mafia
b) If there were, their role text would be word-for-word identical to vanilla town
Which leaves only the possibility that somehow during the night he acquired that text. Possible, but really, remote I think. I also have a long memory and am not willing to simply forget about Day 1 activity. No Robb for me, thanks.
I agree with you initial plan of concentrating on the three investigators. I said so myself. I clear Robb because he passed the "vanillagate" word test by Darko, and I really don't think that:
a) There are any vanilla mafia
b) If there were, their role text would be word-for-word identical to vanilla town
Which leaves only the possibility that somehow during the night he acquired that text. Possible, but really, remote I think. I also have a long memory and am not willing to simply forget about Day 1 activity. No Robb for me, thanks.
I just don't think that we are guaranteed to win by lynching the five you list.
I don't think there is a 100% full-proof plan, neither yours, nor anyone else's.
I believe we should continue with an open mind, evaluating information as it flows in, not make plans for three days ahead.
Hectic workday set to begin in half-an-hour.