man im freaking out every time i think of something to post i think of some way it would make me look Mafia and then persuade my self that i shouldn't post it :(

But on the other hand, if you never post anything of any consequence, that is going to look bad in itself....

But you MUST post! We have to be able to see what's in your mind, whether you're mafia or town! Otherwise the only way to find out what's in there is by autopsy. Sounds like you've got some things to say and by keeping them back you just aren't playing the game. Let's hear it!

Would it be rude to ask our moderator for a votecount?

(And hey! I just worked out (worked out?) that Misser Twiglet's little picture there is a BOOK! I've been seeing as some sort of archaeopteryx!)

I think you'll find it's a samurai type dude!

Even if one is mafia or is power role and fears revealing himself or just is afraid he will be mistaken for mafia he should post. Not only to not get lynched for lurking but more importantly because it's no fun otherwise.

Votecount
3 - Itai.Sharim - Bazilsek, Vitek, Orryyrro
2 - Grynn - Twilightbard, Rodzaju
2 - Damnation - Cruward_Darkeyes, Grynn
1 - Rodzaju - nmillar
1 - Joesapphire - Sirprimalform,
1 - Twilightbard - Damnation
1 - Orryyrro - Joesapphire

Not Voting:Jefequeso, Robbeasy, Itai.Sharim, Quadalien

Itai.Sharim is closest to lynch at L-5

Deadline will either be the 21st Nov(Flexible) or the 12th Dec(Latest) dependant on discussion as thats when I get some time off to write the end of day flavor

heh. Well, I'm still new at the game, and I don't want to accidentally say something that ends with me being mistakenly lynched as mafia. Or draw the Mafia's attention to me, either.

I personally have my own suspicions, but nothing concrete yet.

They'll never be concrete, so why don't you post your reads and suspicions of people?

My Reads:


Joe Sapphire - Don't have any real reason to suspect him, unless I missed something.

Vitek - To be quite honest, I'm kind of suspicious of him. During the whole "Rob" incident, he seemed to be posting JUST enough to look like he was objecting, without actually saying much of substance.

SirPrimalForm - I got nothing here. He hasn't posted enough.

Orryyrro - Again, I don't really have any thoughts here. Apart from his "read," he hasn't posted much.

Cruward_darkeyes - Lurking FAR too much. A little while back I was thinking that it was the lurkers that we needed to be suspicious of (see post 181). But now after seeing how sensitive people are to lurkers, I suspect that experienced Mafia aren't going to draw attention to themselves by lurking. They're going to be the ones jumping on every little nitpicky thing they can to try and establish themseves as Town.

Twilightbard - Haven't really noticed anything from him.

Grynn - I really really doubt that a Mafia member would risk drawing attention to themselves by asking for a nolynch on day 1. The probability of us accidentally lynching a Townie is greatly in their favor. Unless Grynn was making a very poor attempt to try and get the Mafia a free nightkill or something like that.

Rodzaju - As I said before, I don't think his name reveal was anything other than a very poor impulsive attempt to keep people from suspecting him. Were he Mafia, I don't think such a thing would have had any purpose.

Robbeasy - He was my random vote at the beginning, but I don't really have a reason to suspect him. He went after Damnation pretty aggressively, though...

Nmillar - He said he'd be happy to vote for Rob or Grynn or "one of the lurkers," (post 186) which are both groups that I'm less likely to suspect. This isn't really any reason to suspect him, but I think it's worth noting.

Bazilisek - He's one of the more vocal ones, so he's either a very helpful Townie or a Mafia trying to cover his tracks.

Damnation - Well...he's a lurker with a real life reason for lurking...don't know what to think.

QuadrAlien - I had my vote on him for a little bit, but that was mostly just to test the waters.

itai.sharim - Now this guy... I don't know. He's also been a pretty aggressive one, despite his lack of experience. That's a little suspicious to me.


There's some random thoughts. I'm just sorta shooting in the dark and trying to deduce things.

What? You trying to say I'm crazy? What do you mean?

Who do you consider as lurkers?

Sorry guys, I've been unintentionally lurking since my last post. The connection problems were resolved at that point and since then I've just not been keeping up with the thread (until now).

I find Grynn's 'I've played before, no I haven't.' thing much less suspicious than his wish for no one to be lynched (even mafia).

This post was supposed to be much longer, but I have to go somewhere. More tonight, I promise.

Just posting to confirm that I'm still actively keeping up with the goings-on in this thread; off to play football shortly, but will post something more substantial later tonight.

Basically anyone in my read who I said hadn't posted enough for me to form an opinion of them. Damnation, Primal, QuadrAlien, and Cruward_darkeyes are the 4 that come to mind.

Really don't know what to make of the Rod-Baz explosion... as others have said, mafia would have been given the kind of detailed information Rod seems to have. Unless he and Baz are both scum? Well, I should probably go to bed. I've been up all night messing with FamiTracker and I'm a bit manic now.