Witcher 3....Though I -still- need to beat the first two.

As for GTA V. I own it on Xbox, so hype ended for me awhile ago.

comes to a sand box crime game and a RPG. I'm curious which one has more more lively world. Because in one you have a massive world full of NPC's and things to interact with. But with the other almost all NPC's can be spoken to and almost all building can be entered.
What do you mean by lack of creativity. Like as in what you can do or something?

Porque no los dos?

I will most definitely get GTA V when the price drops, and after I can finish GTA 3, SA, VC and IV.

So what are you impression of both games?

The answer is: what do you prefer RPG or Openworld action?
I haven't finished the previous witcher games (though I have loved the parts I played) and its requirements are way too high (I think I can handle them, but I might need some OC for things like boob physics and stuff), so it's a game I WANT to play, but it'll have to wait some time.
On the other hand, I have played (almost) all GTA games and finished a few of them, (which is strange, as I seldom finish games), its requirements are decent (I think I can max it) and its online seems like a great thing to test and play. If it wasn't for the high price (I can't afford that right now) and the DRM, I would have probably bought a retail version by now.
So, I would go with GTA 5 and keep W3 in the top of my wishlist, stalking the wolf ;)

It's about a modern town, what seem to be middle-aged men, completely plausible scenarios etc. Not talking about gameplay elements, just the whole idea. Please note, I said imagination and not creativity.

In the end it's all personal opinion and we'll just leave it at that.

http://www.gamespot.com/articles/common-gta-5-pc-errors-and-how-to-fix-them/1100-6426605/?utm_campaign=54d2d62a71b11e98090044c1&utm_source=weekly_newsletter&utm_medium=email&bt_alias=eyJ1c2VySWQiOiJlYWQ3NjIzNi1mYjRhLTQ2MmQtOTVhNy04MDJmYWVhZjBjYzEifQ%3D%3D

I wish this helps decide. GTA V is a bug-ridden mess. Most bugs plaguing which, is due to DRM, enforced logging, third party account creation/checks (social club) etc. Witcher 3 comes DRM-FREE and without all these harassments and hassle.

Sure, a bug ridden mess that no one is able to play right now.

Once I get a computer capable of running an AAA game, I'd choose Witcher 3 over GTA 5. I really liked the PS3 era GTA games (3 / Vice / SA) but GTA 4 was a complete turnoff for me. Too much realism and not enough of the humor from the previous entries made it through. I have only played the first Witcher, the only one that my current PC can run. It took few tries to get into it but it was worth it. Witcher 3 looks like it could have the size and scope of a GTA game, and that has me excited.

Never did i say no one is able to play it (right now, especially NOW...)! Glad to see people can actually USE the property they bothered to BUY!

That is what i think myself, too. 4 was a f*ing disaster. 3d era was so good...

I have GTAV for the PS4. It's an amazing game, but I can see myself way more immersed in the world of The Witcher 3, which I also plan getting on the PS4. I'm an hardcore Game of Thrones fan, and the Witcher 3 seems like an RPG version of it.

PS I'm aware of the Witcher books pre dates Game of Thrones, but I'm just completely new to the world of The Witcher. :)

I knew Rockstar would fuck up the PC version of GTA 5, just like they did 4. So Witcher 3 has always seemed like an obvious choice to me.

I am happy to see that reasonable, impartial, logical and sensible, fanboy-free people, work for magazines, and help shape opinions and stuff. Kudos to you man!

I never understood why or how people found GTA 4 *OK* on pc, and even better a game than previous titles...

What's so fucked up in GTA V PC? For me it has worked quite well. I get hell of a lot better frames than in IV. I wouldn't say that it is a bad port at all.

I disliked GTA4, Period!!!