Finished The Witcher 2 last night. Some thoughts:
Combat was decently implemented, but the use of traps was too awkward/slow to be really useful. On that note, precision targeting with throwing knives/bombs was entirely useless since by the time I actual got to that point enemies tend to be almost on top of me.
I felt like I wasted those two skill points on throwing knives as it didn't come nearly as handy as I thought it might - bombs are much more useful, in practically any given situation. Thank god I never invested into reflecting arrows since that skill seemed like it would have been a total waste. Key point: monsters (and even most non-monsters) don't use arrows whatsoever.
Aard, Yrden, and Quen seem to have been the most useful signs for me.
The crafting system seemed a bit much at first, but soon enough I figured out all that junk I was carrying around is better left in storage until I actually want to have someone create a specific item for me. Still didn't buy a lot of diagrams or formulas. Guess that's why I ended up with over 4k orens in the bank at the end of the game. At least I had money to waste on the bearded she-elf. What an odd thing to put in the game. =P
While story-wise it does make sense to take potions before a battle, the system in the second game just felt clunky having to meditate for every time I wanted to use a potion. Hence I very rarely did. I definitely liked how much easier it was to craft potions in 2, but on a whole I found the first game's implementation a lot better being able to down one on the go.
On that note, the whole inventory system felt clunky. It served its function, but it was never a real pleasure to navigate. Also switching between menu screens was a bit of a chore. I definitely appreciated how easy it was to browse through the different menu screens in the original.
Side quests tended to be more interesting in the original. Here it felt more like padding out the game for things to do to level up.
Wow. that sure sounds like an awful lot of griping. All that said, I still thoroughly enjoyed the game once I got to grips with some of the differences. Hell, I actually enjoyed the much-maligned QTE scenes. Yeah, I had some good fun.
I'm still debating about pre-ordering the third game. I still have some seven months to think about it, but I wouldn't be surprised if I did. The second game ran quite well with most settings on high, so I expect ought to be able to easily play the former in the medium to high range (or so I hope). Also looks like the interface was changed for the better for part three if this leaked screenie is anything to go by. I really hope that potion slot means I'd be able to once again down them without meditating. Anyway...
/ramble
Now that I got that out of my system, I'm not entirely sure what to play next. I may take a few days break from games since the whole Witcher 1&2 back-to-back run through took up quite a bit of my free time (not to mention sleep time).