joppo: Bosco's original voice was perfectly fine. I don't care if a white guy voices a black character or the black guy voices the white... as long as the voices match the characters' personalities. Which they did.
This sort of decision is worse than useless, it's detrimental to the games.
my name is vaughlte catte: Oh man. Here you go with the opposite side of the outrage coin.
Personally I wouldn't get angry if they
didn't change it but I'm not angry that they
did.
I see both sides: I enjoyed the original portrayal, but I can also appreciate why some people might (quite reasonably) find it offensive. It's not just the fact the actor is white, it's the fact he was doing a somewhat exaggerated racial stereotype voice.
I'm a bit disappointed that you've been sucked into the outrage vortex.
I'm just annoyed at them going out of their way to appease racism claims that were never done, because there had never been any basis for such claims anyway. A disembodied voice, which is all that the actor leaves in a game,
does not have a skin color.
Which is why I don't mind if the actor voicing a character is white, black, green with three suction cups, caucasian, asian, martian... As long as they do a good job with the voices I will gladly consume their product. It can't be any
less racist than that!
I'm with Breja in this matter. Bosco is simply a silly character, not a jab at black-skinned people. I (and I am certain many in this forum) consider myself a bit nerdy and I don't enjoy Maniac Mansion any less because Bernard is a blatant nerd stereotype. I don't demand the game be redone with a more positive interpretation, I just chuckle at his silly clothes, hair and overall portrayal. It is a game that revels in being silly. Just like Sam and Max, you know.
I'm not even saying Bosco's new voice is worse right away. Who knows, maybe they managed to find someone who voices him even better than the original actor. I am just saying that the whole debacle is based on a non-issue to begin with. And also that, by restricting the pool of voice actors
based on skin colors they might not end with the best voice the character could have.
Lastly, I have a question for you. You said that Bosco's original voice portrays a racial stereotype, which I assume you meant as in derogatory to black-skinned people. (I don't see it that way but that's subjective anyway.) So does it becomes okay if the stereotypes are just remade by a black guy? Or in case the supposed stereotypes have to be changed, how far does he have to go to appease this imaginary "racial outrage" crowd? Should the new Bosco have a Cockney accent? Speak like an oil magnate? Where is the limit?