Space and Flight Sim/Shooter and other Sim
Star Wars: Rogue Squadron 3D, #6 most wished game in this category is now released and left the list. Theme Park World (aka Sim Theme Park) entered the list.

Shooter
Jedi Knight - Dark Forces II , #9 most wished game in this category is released and therefore left the list. SWAT 4 entered the list.
Max Payne now has more votes than No One Lives Forever 2.
Alien vs Predator 2 now has more votes than Quake.

Adventure
Monkey Island 2: LeChuck's Revenge is now released and therefore left the list. Removed Silent Hill 2 as well as I now think it fits slightly more to the Action genre.

The Neverhood and Escape from Monkey Island entered the list.

PS: I will update the Action genre later.

Action/Platformer/Puzzle
Now I consider Silent Hill series as part of this genre (they kind of fit a bit of action and a bit of puzzle). Therefore, Silent Hill 2 and Silent Hill entered the list, pushing Resident Evil and Resident Evil 2 out.
Lemmings now has more votes than Jazz Jackrabbit.
Jazz Jackrabbit 2 now has more votes than The Elder Scrolls Adventures: Redguard.

Crowdfunded
Sattelite Reign is now officially confirmed and therefore left the list. Darkest Dungeon entered the list from #3. Several games, especially Serpent in the Staglands moved up in the list.

Crowdfunded
Dex entered the list from #5, pushing Armikrog out.

Just want to say thanks and +1 for all your work in keeping this list updated.

you are welcome! I would appreciate any help, reminders everytime a game moves up in ranks or should be on the list but isn't :)

Missing stuff, Superior Versions...
Star Wars: X-Wing Collector's CD-ROM and Star Wars: TIE Fighter Collector's CD-ROM, both sharing the top of the list, are released and therefore left the list. Neverwinter Nights: Infinite Dungeons and Neverwinter Nights: Wyvern Crown of Cormyr are back in.

Duke Nukem 3D: Duke It Out In DC is the new king of the list!

Crowdfunded
Serpent in the Staglands is confirmed for release and therefore left the list. It was replaced by Shadowrun: Hong Kong, which entered the list from #3.

Crowdfunded
Prison Architect now has more votes than Planetary Annihilation.

Crowdfunded
Underworld Ascendant and Starbound entered the list from #3 and #6, pushing Grim Dawn and Mighty No. 9 out.

Crowdfunded
Shadowrun: Hong Kong is officially confirmed and therefore left the list. HuniePop entered the list from #6.

RPG
The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind increased its votes and taken over the crown for most wanted RPG, pushing Diablo to the 2nd position. Diablo II now has more votes than Vampire: The Masquerade - Bloodlines. The Elder Scrolls II: Daggerfall now has more votes than Final Fantasy VII.

Racing/Sports/Fighting
Rankings in this category have completely changed and Star Wars: Episode I - Racer is the new king of the list! Need for Speed II: Special Edition now entered the list, pushing The Need for Speed: Special Edition out.