While I don't disagree with you at all in principle, what can we learn from her lynch??

Well, it's not special other than probably being one of the most famous. That's not why I would think him scum for claiming pikachu mind you. It's all largely irrelevant now as the cat's out the bag.
As I said, I rather bollocksed it up. I should have sat on it for another in game day and waited for the evidence to build up.

With how it was so far she needs to either start participating pronto or, more likely, just sub out as she is not playing.
To lynch her would be wasting our lynch, though, and it is exactly what I would call low-hanging fruit.
It gives us no information whatsoever and we'd be basically doing mods work at expense of 1 Day.
Sure, she may flip mafia, but it wil be mostly just random chance of hit.


You would have saved yourself a lot of embarassment. :-p

Let's confirm your alignment before we jump to that particular conclusion.

Well, Pikachu being one of the few Pokemon I actually recognize, I noticed that Vitek was pretending to be one. (Avatar + Lightning based powers) But I saw that as fluff. I don't see how claiming Pikachu would make him scum or why, if he is scum, he would want to false-claim Pikachu if he isn't one.

Care to explain where your leap of thought from: "He is pretending to be Pikachu" to "He is scum" came from?

Town doesn't lie.

I think Sage needs a sub. It's not even a case of lurking. She seemingly isn't able to log in. Maybe we could use ZFR as a sub.

Generally it's a no no to sub in ex-players, even if the ex-player was VT.

Ah, OK. I can accept that as reason and if he actually had claimed Pikachu while you have proof that he can't be one, I would totally get behind that lynch. But he didn't claim Pikachu, which means he didn't lie. And basing a lynch on Avatar tomfoolery is a bad idea as the last game showed.

You're right, I have no proof because I prematurely accusated. Only time will tell whether I was onto something.
For the record, it wasn't the avatar that did it for me but the attacks
Well, off to do some work - I'll be back at lunch.

*poke poke* Are you still playing?

(no, this poke wasn't a vote. Otherwise it would be bolded.)

HypersomniacLive and Hunter65536 expressed willingness to sub earlier.

Other things don't lie either.


I'll take it.
I promise I am going to build case against myself if her role turns out ot be mafia.


I need to do another overview. Mostly for myself.
T-->S

Vítek - Stung himself in gum with thorn from flower while sitting at work. ZFR thought him mafia for allegedly noticing his false lovers crumbs.

Lifhtrasil - mostly like his reads. Was onto ZFR but after ZFR dragged him there himself. Suspected by adaila and most of the time by ZFR but he warmed up to him towards end.

flubbucket - very usual himself. No reason to consider town but also none to vote.

trentonlf - started the ZFR wagon who turned out to be town. Most of D1 was his tunnelly self. Correctly believed ZFR and jumped off his wagon quite early into his claim. After unvoting ZFR voted Lift for no apparent reason? No voting Sage for being scum for her absence - not liking that.

Sage - empty spot - null to scum - needs to sub out or be here.

MChack - only person I couldn't remember while making list. I felt like he was trying earlier but I have lsot sight of him. Kinda scummy.

sIRpIMALFORM - lurking hard but it is also his town MO. Voted only me for avatar, yog for his opening post (which I didn't like either but SPF did nothing else than this) and ZFR to secure any lynch. Voted without proper reasoning and when asked about it said we should imagine he voted without saying anything as it was to make it better.
I had the impression he is making grounds for claiming fake result on me but instead turned into this silliness.
Am disappointed he thinks so little of me.

yogsloth - not doing much, tried to appear as very non-harmful D1 and claimed PR in weird way.

scenography - still not sure about him. Gives a vibe of newbie trying to find the right direction but somewhat it feel wrong to me. Didn't like his fearmongering I mentioned before and Wyrm suspected him with case I can get behind for sure. Voting Sage for absence and because she had most vote ATM (not true). Leaning scum right now.

adalia - subbed in after newbie who couldn't handle scum role. Bookwyrm named his as scum for weak reasons. His main suspects D1 were ZFR and Wyrm. Is voting absent player. Assured suplement that if one of them is bussed they can still win with rest of the team. Gave us analysis that there is prolly scum player on lynch wagon and scum player off it. ZFR called him mafia too.


So what have I learnt from my incoherent look through the thread?
That everybody's but me is mafia but most of you only partially.


I am going to Skull bash adalia right now but it needs more research.

Random addendum: Some people said scene plays similar to his liberal play in SH but no one experienced him as mafia AFAIK, so I am not sure how is it feasible to compare it.

Not against any game rules no. You could have a look at previous games to see how people have played before. But yeah, many have the advantage of having played games with other players, so whatever you want to do to try and catch up is up to you.

Okay thanks for letting me know. I'll get right on it.

Thanks, deputy announcer, for covering my duties while I went to the toilet.

Battle Update!

3 - Sage103082 is being attacked by trentonlf & yogsloth & adaliabooks
3 - SirPrimalform is being attacked by Lifthrasil, supplementscene & mchack
1 - adaliabooks is being attacked by Vitek
1 - yogsloth is being attacked by flubbucket
1 - Vitek is being attacked by SirPrimalform

0 - Lifthrasil
0 - mchack
0 - Flubbucket
0 - trentonlf
0 - supplementscene
aren't being attacked.

and Sage103082 isn't attacking anybody.

It'll take 6 attackers to eliminate a player.