You'll have to bold if you want that to be counted.

I have an inclining what you might be doing (or what role you might have) but I'm not sure, and it certainly doesn't rule you out being scum.

As for this part;

"Meanwhile, I always pick up votes. I'm always going to be one of the leading wagons. So do they spend a NK on me as a suspected PR, or do they think they might be able to lynch me? Could they really pull that off?"

I'm not sure I buy that. How many times have you been lynched again here? Have you ever actually been lynched here? Sure, you do get votes now and again (quite often from me) but I'm not sure Mafia would ever count on being able to lynch you.

Now straight up claiming scum D1 when you are scum... that is something I can see you doing.

My vote stays for now.


Did I NK you in the end? I didn't think I had... I don't suppose I owe you anything then :P (that was a joke anyway).
There is no score, I was mostly just joking.
I have found you a little suspicious but nothing really vote worthy, I'll probably do a reread on you ('cause, you know, no one is saying anything and rereads are quite easy this game) to clarify or clear up my suspicions when I have a chance.

When I said SPF and yog both willingly claimed scum I wasn't much more seroius then when I sadi my stat is 18. ;-)


I have no idea what are you talking about.

Zero public analysis.

By the way, you need to bold that if you want it to count.

Well ok. Since I've bollocksed it up, there's no reason to keep it secret.

All through this game I've been watching Vitek laying the groundwork (in a breadcrumby sort of way) for a claim later on, one that I have a reasonable cause to think is false. However, after I started focusing on him today it would appear that he's stopped so he can deny it. I probably should have sat on this longer and let him dig a deeper hole, but never mind.

I'm referring to these votes:

https://www.gog.com/forum/general/gog_mafia_54_pokemon_death_tournament/post118
https://www.gog.com/forum/general/gog_mafia_54_pokemon_death_tournament/post167
https://www.gog.com/forum/general/gog_mafia_54_pokemon_death_tournament/post257
https://www.gog.com/forum/general/gog_mafia_54_pokemon_death_tournament/post280
https://www.gog.com/forum/general/gog_mafia_54_pokemon_death_tournament/post383

That is all of Vitek's votes apart from the first vote and the most recent vote (which I believe is only different because he'd worked out what I'd spotted by this point).

Vitek, j'accuse...!

So you assume he was going to claim some kind of electric type Pokemon presumably?
Considering his avatar was Pikachu he may well have been just theming his attacks accordingly...

You say you are reasonably sure it's false, which would mean you either know what Pokemon he is (not electric type) or you are an electric type that you believe he is going to claim (hard to see considering there are quite a few, even if we are sticking with just first gen [which may or may not be the case]).

For a moment I wondered if we only had one Pokemon of each type in the game, but with only twelve players we'd be three types short for that too work, so there is no reason to believe each type is unique..


So basically I have no idea what you are getting at.

And you don't wonder why he chose a pikachu and only changed it to squirtle after I voted for him?

You're mostly there. I think he was leaving breadcrumbs to help with a falseclaim down the road. Specifically, I think he was preparing to claim pikachu.

He'll deny it now of course, but then who wouldn't?

Changes vote from Sage to elbow smashing SirPrimalform's nose


Also guys the Pokeman references hold no reference for me, I was in Uni when it came out. @Adalia's last post went right over my head

But isn't that scummy because as town you're supposed to help other townees with your analysis. Unless ofcourse you're vanilla and self sacrificing. I don't get your point unless there's someone I'm not seeing? So he voted ZFR (who seemed suspicious), Bookwyrm, Adalia/Deadbot (who seemed suspicious curtesy of being suicidal) and yourself.

Defending Lift perhaps? Or just that he voted for 2 players who died?

There simply isn't much to go on here imo. WAIT ARE YOU ACTUALLY USING POKEMAN AS REASONING??? I don't have a clue about Pokeman or the significance....

I goto say guys the Mafia bad guys here are giving far fewer tells than the Secret Hitler bad guys. This is actually really hard when Mafia don't give anything away. I'm back to thinking it's largely a game of luck.

But... what benefit is there to him fake claiming Pikachu? Particularly as Pikachu is quite possibly likely to be a player in the game (considering it is the most well known Pokemon).

No.

...and you would get lynched over it, if you are found out lying. Lynch all liars, remenber? I think Town should never lie! In my experience that always creates more trouble for town that for scum. Look at how lying turned out for ZFR. So I say if you are town, your soft-claim was bad play. But I can see reasons for you to reveal a block if you are scum. If you are scum and you were blocked, the blocking was done by some townie. Perhaps you hope that by being honest about it, whoever it was will reconsider in the next night and not block you again. 'Yogs was honest, so he must be town'. Is that what you are going for? Or did you even hope that whoever blocked you would come out and say: 'Yep, that was me. My bad.' ? ... Or you are town with a super-useless PR and you want to draw the NK. But in that case you just told scum that that might be the case.


@SPF: Really? Your reason for suspecting Vitek is, that you were under the impression that Vitek was preparing a Pikachu claim? While you have information that he can't be Pikachu. ... But why would any scum false-claim the single most well known Pokemon that is almost sure to be in the game? Any scum doing so could be almost sure that he would be counter-claimed. Also, what would scum-Vitek gain by claiming Pikachu? We don't have any guarantee that flavour-Pokemon-types are connected to alignment. A Pikachu could be Mafia and a Meowth could be town. Who knows. At least I would randomize the alignments if I were a mod, like it was done in the Galactica game.

No, this reasoning for your 'suspicion' doesn't make sense. I still think that you are scummy. So my vote stays.

But if necessary I could also get on board with a yogs or Sage lynch. Yogs for his soft-claim shenanigans and Sage for absence.

Please enlighten someone who has absolutely no clue about Pokemon, why would a pikachu matter?? Is it some sore of special Pokemon? And what would Vitek claiming it mean?

Just out of curiosity, what types are there?

Eh, let's see if I can do this without looking it up;

Normal
Fire
Water
Grass
Bug
Electric
Flying
Rock
Ground
Fighting
Psychic
Ghost
Poison
Ice
Dragon

And remembered all but one without looking it up!

If we're going by later games there are also;

Steel
Dark
Fairy

(maybe others, I haven't played too many of the recent games).

So far we have had:

Tangela - Grass
Primeape - Fighting

So no duplicates yet, but that's not surprising considering we only have two flips.

You know what?

It's been four days since Sage has posted... whether she's scum or town she's not really helping one single bit here. I'm fine with that lynch.

Unvote
Tackle Sage