Posted February 03, 2020
A Plague Tale: Innocence (XB1X)
A new Game Pass edition last month. I went into this not expecting to really like it since it's described as being quite cinematic and is compared to Hellblade or The Last of Us- not my favourite games. Actually I ended up liking it better than those games, but I'd put it more as an average 3.5-4 star game maybe- about the same as my favourite story driven cinematic games like Quantum Break, Alan Wake and Until Dawn (yes I liked that one for some reason).
It is cinematic, but at least it mostly keeps it's cutscenes and interruptions at the start and end of chapters and only occasionally messes with you during actual gameplay. It is quite a technical achievement though, awesome visuals- especially the texture work and lighting, maybe not as strong with character animations. But impressive for a smallish studio. It ran perfectly as well and had no bugs at all.
What mainly dragged the game down a notch was the overall story, which basically sets the type of gameplay. It's an escort quest where you escort the worlds most annoying whiny kid. Who, despite being in almost continuous life threatening situations, still finds plenty of time to whine and run ahead and just make me want to thrash him. The other characters were a bit better. I see a lot of reviews criticise the gameplay as being too repetitive, but it's not an overly long game and I thought it introduced just enough new facets to it's formula at regular points to prevent total boredom. Put it this way, it's got far more variety than Hellblade did.
I was not convinced about the story though. To be honest not much of it ended up making any real sense. I still don't really know what was wrong with the kid (apart from being annoying I mean) or why. I don't know how the Inquisition even knew about him to begin with, or what the bad guy was truly trying to achieve other than just being an asshat.
Like always these days, people that love it rate it 5 stars and those that didn't rate it 1 star. No one ever rates game in between anymore, yet that's exactly where I think this sits. Worth playing through if you're after something short and story driven- I just hope you like the story better than I did. Odd bit of trivia, the other game being developed by Asobo Studios is Microsoft Flight Simulator, and I wouldn't be surprised if MS buys the studio sometime this year.
A new Game Pass edition last month. I went into this not expecting to really like it since it's described as being quite cinematic and is compared to Hellblade or The Last of Us- not my favourite games. Actually I ended up liking it better than those games, but I'd put it more as an average 3.5-4 star game maybe- about the same as my favourite story driven cinematic games like Quantum Break, Alan Wake and Until Dawn (yes I liked that one for some reason).
It is cinematic, but at least it mostly keeps it's cutscenes and interruptions at the start and end of chapters and only occasionally messes with you during actual gameplay. It is quite a technical achievement though, awesome visuals- especially the texture work and lighting, maybe not as strong with character animations. But impressive for a smallish studio. It ran perfectly as well and had no bugs at all.
What mainly dragged the game down a notch was the overall story, which basically sets the type of gameplay. It's an escort quest where you escort the worlds most annoying whiny kid. Who, despite being in almost continuous life threatening situations, still finds plenty of time to whine and run ahead and just make me want to thrash him. The other characters were a bit better. I see a lot of reviews criticise the gameplay as being too repetitive, but it's not an overly long game and I thought it introduced just enough new facets to it's formula at regular points to prevent total boredom. Put it this way, it's got far more variety than Hellblade did.
I was not convinced about the story though. To be honest not much of it ended up making any real sense. I still don't really know what was wrong with the kid (apart from being annoying I mean) or why. I don't know how the Inquisition even knew about him to begin with, or what the bad guy was truly trying to achieve other than just being an asshat.
Like always these days, people that love it rate it 5 stars and those that didn't rate it 1 star. No one ever rates game in between anymore, yet that's exactly where I think this sits. Worth playing through if you're after something short and story driven- I just hope you like the story better than I did. Odd bit of trivia, the other game being developed by Asobo Studios is Microsoft Flight Simulator, and I wouldn't be surprised if MS buys the studio sometime this year.
Post edited February 03, 2020 by CMOT70