Giant Squid? What is the theme of the game?
Twenty Thousand Leagues Under the Sea?
Normally Mafia games end in binary Win/Lose for the players. This particular game will feature a leader board at the end. Each player will have objectives to complete in order to score points, and point totals will be presented at the end.
Am I the only one that reads this as "forum mafia game with achievements"?
I'm not sure I understand how this unusual works. What exactly is the point of the leader board? Will there be no Win/Lose condition? If there will be, how will the "objectives/scoring points" side impact the main quest of he game?
Regarding the poll:
1) Deadline length - I'm with JMich on this (post #11), though I don't know why he prefers longer Days, especially at the beginning - number of players + location of players (time-zones) should be taken into account. As the game progresses and players die, the deadlines could adjust.
2) Lack of consensus at Deadline - I have to say no interferences from the dead/observer thread, as it could mess with the outcome/balance of the game.
And I'd like to hear a little more about the theme/setup of the game.