bram1253: What's the best Role Playing Game (RPG) ever made (in your opinion)?
Here are some really good ones:
Final Fantasy 7
Ultima 7
[...]
I wouldn't consider those games to be particularly good. FF7 has numerous issues that make it a poor game and significantly inferior to its predecessor, while U7 has horrible real-time combat.
The best Final Fantasy game is, by far, Final Fantasy 5.
Smannesman: AD&D 2nd Edition.
But that's mostly nostalgia talking.
That system has way too many issues for me to put it up there when comparing it to other Pencil and Paper RPGs. It has a whole bunch of ugly (exceptional Strength) and ridiculous (15 Strength not better combat-wise than 8). Not to mention the clunky magic system.
bram1253: In my opinion Morrowind is the best RPG because it has a gigantic amount of depth to it.
You can literally go steal the souls of gods and make super powerful items with their souls.
That game has too many bugs and balance issues to put it anywhere near the title of "Best RPG Ever Made".
InfraSuperman: Oh, and Elder Scrolls 2: Daggerfall as well.
That game is even *buggier* than Morrowind.