I'm sure there are old threads like this but I'm interested to see what everyone's current list would be.

For me:

1. Fallout
2. Realms of the Haunting
3. Another World(just played this for the first time and greatly enjoyed it)
4. Shogo: Mobile Armor Divison
5. Rayman Forever

The Witcher
Still Life
FlatOut
Unreal Tournament 2004
Far Cry

Something like that.

Fallout 2
Heroes Of M&M 3
Unreal Tournament
Desperados
Commandos Ammo Pack

In no particular order:

Beyond Good & Evil
Baldur's Gate II
The Longest Journey
Psychonauts
The Last Express

Although The Witcher should be thrown in as well, just I like to highlight games others probably wouldn't have in their top 5 list.

The top line of my game page has:

Commandos Ammo Pack
Port Royale
Beneath a Steel Sky
Divine Divinity
Arcanum

That's what you meant, right? ; )

No I meant favorite top 5. lolololol I almost added BG&E but decided not to since I played it on console. Great game. I hope more people play with it coming to XBL/PSN.

Just messin'

Hard to say. About half my library is still unplayed. Of those I have played, I can safely place two in my Top 5:

- I-War 2
- Total Annihilation

I have high hopes for The Guild, Gothic II, Space Rangers 2, Panzer Elite, IL2, and I-War 1. Won't know until someone invents the clock stretcher to give us 30-hour days.

1. Fallout 2
2. Gothic 2
3. Planescape: Tornment
4. Heroes of Might and Magic 3
5. Arcanum

1. Baldur's Gate
2. Unreal Tournament
3. Heroes of Might and Magic III
4. Fallout
5. Planescape: Torment

Empire Earth II: Gold Edition
Heroes of Might and Magic 3: Complete Edition
Master of Magic
Spellforce Platinum
Vampire the Masquerade: Redemption

1.Planescape: Torment
2.Fallout 2
3.Fallout
4.Gabriel Knight
5/ The Witcher

Honorable mention: Arcanum

I only bought the Witcher on GOG though, played the others off discs.

Yeah time to necro this post :D

Might and magic 4/5
Lands of lore
Baldurs gate
Arcanum
Colonizations

Freespace 2
The Might and Magic 6-pack
Ultima Underworld 1+2
Guilty Gear X2
HOMM

This is in no particular order but:

Pandora Directive
Planescape: Torment
Gabriel Knight
Fallout 2
Ultima VII Pt 1&2

I'd like to honourable mention Arcanum, Neverwinter Nights and Phantasmagoria.

For newer released titles on GOG.com I would like to add:

Blackwell Bundle
Alan Wake
Treasure Adventure Game
The Whispered World
and Legend of Grimrock

With Tiny & Big, Resonance and Retro City Rampage all looking like they are going to be a blast too.

Police quest 1-4
Torment
Baldur
The witcher
Anachronox