I cant believe this the next roll after posting this came up with it. amazeballs

I can't seem to get anything other than the common titles from the pots. I've tried dozens of times with different combinations.

Same here. :/

For those who aren't having much luck, I have this triple-rare cart available still.

Amnesia: A Machine For Pigs
Deadly Premonition: Director's Cut
Aarklash: Legacy
Alien Shooter 2: Reloaded
Ittle Dew

I can still roll double-rare carts, but they are becoming more infrequent. Also, I have not once gotten Cognition or Outlast to appear.

I really wonder what affects which items show up. I have rolled so many times without variations that I am fairly certain it simply is not going to happen.

It's annoying because you expect it to be completely random but the evidence points against it. Perhaps some users are simply unable to get the rarer games because of some combination of games owned already?

It looks to me like you have to own all of the basic games before the engine will cough up the good stuff. Which makes sense, of course, especially since the playing field wouldn't be level once we learned how to cherry-pick: people would just harvest the rares and leave the rest. It's a sensible approach to the commerce of it, though it's kind of a damper on the trigger-finger fun side of things.

Yeah that makes sense.

But I am sure as hell not buying Puddle, Iddle Dew, Aqua Kitty, Mutant Blobs Attack and one of those Shooter games to find out.

I wanted Book of Unwritten Tales, Critter Chronicles, and then I included The Inner World and 2 pots of gold.

Is it worth it to buy those 3 and Painkiller Black & I Have No Mouth & I Must Scream for $13?

Are Deponia 3 and Memoria really on the list for this pot of gold promo?

I have spent over $30 on this pot off gold promo over weekend hoping to score at least either Deponia 3 and Memoria but I ended up with some Alien/Zombie shooters plus few lesser games which I don't think I will ever want to play.

And after $30 spent, every time I re-added new set of 5 pot of gold I get the message that the purchase must be a gift because I already owned all five games picked randomly.

I repeated adding post of gold and went through the check out process over 20 times and every time I get the same message that I already owned all five games...

Basically I did not receive any "big title" games at all for my participation in this pot of gold promo.
Very frustrated!!

How are you getting Memoria? Ugh, stupid GOG won't ever roll that one for me :-(

I just recently had it go by again. Want me to pick up a cart for you with it? Let me know your other selections if so.

Nawh, it's ok but thank-you for the kind offer.

Glad to do it. I've rolled up a few carts for folks this morning, it's been fun.

Tried my luck with that pot of gold thing, should not have. What a waste of money.

Geneforce 1-5
Penumbra Collection
Tales from space: Mutant blobs attack
Puddle
ittle Dew

If someone rolls out a pot of gold with Deponia 3, Memoria or Amnesia: A Machine for Pigs they don't need/want, I'd be interested.

EDIT: Thanks ChocoboSlayer for Deponia 3.