It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
avatar
Vitek:
You asked about my investigation of Twilight:

Pretty much the whole room is gilded.
With the chandelier lit, it looks like you’re inside the sun.
Huge 4 poster bed.
Massive gold chair.
WIth the light bouncing from wall to wall, I was getting a headache, so didn't stay long.
Twilight was NOT in his room while I was there.
avatar
Vitek:
avatar
Rodzaju: You asked about my investigation of Twilight:

Pretty much the whole room is gilded.
With the chandelier lit, it looks like you’re inside the sun.
Huge 4 poster bed.
Massive gold chair.
WIth the light bouncing from wall to wall, I was getting a headache, so didn't stay long.
Twilight was NOT in his room while I was there.
OK, let me summarise this.
Night 1 you investigated me. You found out I collect stuff smelling like fish and seashells. Out of this he made assumption I am Walrus.

Night 2 you investigated nmillar. You found he is handyman, has room full of contraptions and makes moustraps. He claims he is the White Knight and this fits his claim.

Night 3 you investigated TwilightBard. His room was gilded and had a throne. He was the White King so flavour fits again.

Then, on night 4, you investigated QuadrAlien. You found out he has a lot of bandages with name labels. He was Caterpillar. This time it doesn't fit at all. Yes he was doctor and this fits to doctor but why? So you always got flavour for character and suddenly you got role flavour?
avatar
Rodzaju: You asked about my investigation of Twilight:

Pretty much the whole room is gilded.
With the chandelier lit, it looks like you’re inside the sun.
Huge 4 poster bed.
Massive gold chair.
WIth the light bouncing from wall to wall, I was getting a headache, so didn't stay long.
Twilight was NOT in his room while I was there.
avatar
Vitek: OK, let me summarise this.
Night 1 you investigated me. You found out I collect stuff smelling like fish and seashells. Out of this he made assumption I am Walrus.

Night 2 you investigated nmillar. You found he is handyman, has room full of contraptions and makes moustraps. He claims he is the White Knight and this fits his claim.

Night 3 you investigated TwilightBard. His room was gilded and had a throne. He was the White King so flavour fits again.

Then, on night 4, you investigated QuadrAlien. You found out he has a lot of bandages with name labels. He was Caterpillar. This time it doesn't fit at all. Yes he was doctor and this fits to doctor but why? So you always got flavour for character and suddenly you got role flavour?
I got flavour info, it just wasn't relevant as he had been revealed.

The bandages were in the front of a drawer FULL of socks.
Loads of socks.
More socks than I've ever seen in one place.

This would probably have led me to Catterpillar.
I think the point of the bandages was to suggest that he had been with you.

I did think the Bandages oddly specific at the time.
Perhaps Baz wrote that after he had been killed so it made no difference.
Frankly I don't know.

But it is these seemingly odd phrases or sentences that turn out to be significant that made me question your teddy bear.
Before you ask, the bits that stuck out to me were:
Vitek - teddy bear, alrming rainbow decor, porcelain statue of ballet dancers.

Nmillar - mousetraps, the bed is the only comfy looking furniture in the whole room.

Twilight - Almost no furniture (Apart from the bed & chair, the room was empty, so where are his clothes?), no-one home but the chandalier fully lit.

Quad - Bandages, large freestanding mirror.
avatar
Rodzaju: Vitek - teddy bear, alrming rainbow decor, porcelain statue of ballet dancers.
Does this sound like a walrus?
avatar
Rodzaju: Vitek - teddy bear, alrming rainbow decor, porcelain statue of ballet dancers.
avatar
nmillar: Does this sound like a walrus?
No, no it does not. Too bad it also doesn't seem to fit with the collecting things that smelled like fish that Rod claimed earlier that led him to the conclusion of Walrus. unvote, vote Rodzaju

Also, Vitek claimed to have attempted to use his friendly neighbor ability that night and was blocked.
avatar
nmillar: Does this sound like a walrus?
And Chesire Cat you "offered me" to be DOES have a Teddy Bear and collect sea shells and have a porcelaine statue of ballet dancers?
avatar
nmillar: Does this sound like a walrus?
avatar
Orryyrro: No, no it does not. Too bad it also doesn't seem to fit with the collecting things that smelled like fish that Rod claimed earlier that led him to the conclusion of Walrus. unvote, vote Rodzaju

Also, Vitek claimed to have attempted to use his friendly neighbor ability that night and was blocked.
Interesting....
You OMGUS vote me.
This gets no support, so you jump on Nmillars Nolynch.
You hint that you have 2 suspects, which will resolve into 1 when the other dies.
Nmillar abandons Nolynch.
So you jump back to me.
What happened to the other suspect?

What I said about Vitek was:
"You collect junk, including sea shells & stuff that smells of fish."
The statue was among his junk.
The teddy bear & the decor are, in my opinion, not conected to the junk.
That's one of the reasons they stand out.
avatar
nmillar: Does this sound like a walrus?
avatar
Orryyrro: No, no it does not. Too bad it also doesn't seem to fit with the collecting things that smelled like fish that Rod claimed earlier that led him to the conclusion of Walrus. unvote, vote Rodzaju

Also, Vitek claimed to have attempted to use his friendly neighbor ability that night and was blocked.
Vitek told Rodzaju that he was correct, so has claimed to be the walrus. Rodzaju could simply have got it wrong and Vitek used this opportunity to make a false claim.
avatar
Vitek: And Chesire Cat you "offered me" to be DOES have a Teddy Bear and collect sea shells and have a porcelaine statue of ballet dancers?
That's not the point; you claimed walrus, but the evidence from Rodzaju's investigation suggests that's not true. Clearly you're not the Cheshire Cat either, but you most certainly aren't the walrus.
avatar
nmillar: That's not the point; you claimed walrus, but the evidence from Rodzaju's investigation suggests that's not true. Clearly you're not the Cheshire Cat either, but you most certainly aren't the walrus.
Why do you pick only the parts that fit your theory of me not being Walrus? You seem to omit the parts that doesn't stick with your attack against me.
Also you know of no one in Wonderland having Teddy (or the other things) so why do you think it makes me someone else than I claimed?

Also I am still torn whom to vote. Upon rereading I figured out that if everybody was alive you 3 and Typhoon would be most likely candidates for being mafia. Good work, people. :-P

I have been thinking about nolynch but I am not sure it will tell anything.
From my perspective if nmillar gets NKed it will tell me nothing about who did this. Orryyrro and Rod will still target each other and I'll have to choose. I'll most likely pick Orryyrro so it's nothing worth delaying.

If I get killed I will have no perspective anymore. Then Orryyrro gets lynched "again" as both Rod and nmillar see him as most possible scum.

If Orryyrro gets killed it will change my view of the game a lot, I admit. He is big suspect in everyones eyes and probably mafia so I don't think he'll get killed.

If Rodzaju gets killed then I still will have to choose between Orryyrro and nmillar. No win for me. One of you will be scum and I'll have to decide the same way I have to now. Yes, there will be bigger chance but still it's just case of blindly deciding with no further info. Nmillar will have his two targets still alive and will have to choose who to lynch from his two biggest suspects and two of his biggest suspects will have power to decide. Orryyrro will have to find new target but because I suspect him most I think it will be no big deal for him. There is still the possibility Orryyrro lied about his role and will be afraid of being investigated and kills Rod but I don't think Rodz will be able to find anything.

With this said I think you figured out I am not in favor of nolynch.
avatar
Vitek: With this said I think you figured out I am not in favor of nolynch.
Your reluctance to nolynch just confirms you as mafia. You've stated yourself that your vote will be on Orryrro no matter what, so what difference does it make if that vote is cast today or tomorrow?
avatar
nmillar: Your reluctance to nolynch just confirms you as mafia. You've stated yourself that your vote will be on Orryrro no matter what, so what difference does it make if that vote is cast today or tomorrow?
What? How does it confirms me? I could go to nolynch, kill you and then choose from Orryyrro or Rodzaju at ease.
avatar
Vitek: What? How does it confirms me? I could go to nolynch, kill you and then choose from Orryyrro or Rodzaju at ease.
1 in 4 chance for town to get it right today. 1 in 3 chance for the town to get it right tomorrow. It is in the mafia's interest to end the game today.
avatar
nmillar: 1 in 4 chance for town to get it right today. 1 in 3 chance for the town to get it right tomorrow. It is in the mafia's interest to end the game today.
And it's easier for mafia to get mislynch.
Your theory counts with some nameless mafia, yet you think it's me and it would be benefical for me to push nolynch and kill you.