We can all vote for me and possibly end it. Wolves running through the halls....

We can also consider the possibility, considered throughout the thread, that there are 2 scum and that they have the power to overcome the numbers by talking during the day or talking prior to Day 1. A mason claim is perfect.

This consideration doesn't negate the possibility that there is another.

Sorry mrk I also found this to be poor wording or slip from you.

I was referring to the videos linked here (http://www.gog.com/forum/general/gog_forum_mafia_22_werewolf/post21).
Enjoy.

For now I am unvoting. I am need to re read the posts and think on things.

Unvote budejovice

@mrkgnao

Look again at our thread. Check my post #40. This is what I was talking about.

I'm not sure I follow exactly. Which sentences of post #40? There are 5 sentences there.

Point your attention to sentences #3 & #4.

Got you!

So, first things first.

I'm not planning to do this alone and assume some form of leadership. It's a risky gamble for both sides and we are still in no rush to resort to such measures.

Now that we have trent and budejovice's claims I would like to ask the rest of the group - what are your thoughts about them? In addition we can look back and re-visit everyone else's claim, too. I'll keep silent for the time being, but I have my own views, which I'll share at some point.

Generally speaking, both sound plausible.

Of the two I find budejovice's less convincing because: (a) a flavour cop could just as easily be a scum role, (b) it sounds excessive to have both a cop and a flavour cop on the town side, (c) I cannot find any correlation between a wide receiver and a flavour cop (but I must admit I know nothing about American football).

trentonlf's is more credible, even though it too could be a scum role (substitute bullet with lynch).

Even though you didn't ask, I find RWarehall's the most convincing of today's claims. I put his claim almost on par with Sage's. I disagree with flub here. The wiki states clearly that a jailkeeper/roleblocker only blocks active abilities. "Passive abilities, such as a Bulletproof player's kill immunity or a Mason's ability to privately talk, are not affected".

I did ask :)

I think the best thing to do now is to go back and re-visit everyone's claims and roles (including the fallen ones)and try and pinpoint the one(s) that seem least plausible and go from there.

And for the record, I'm not in the "Cheerleaders are scum" camp per se. All I did was raise the possibility. Scum masquerading as Masons is a thing, I've heard of it done before. The game flips on your status for sure. Even then, I'm just not sure. And given last game, where I took a bit of a lead and was wrong every time, I'm not sure I can trust my instincts one way or another.

At this point, I'm rather convinced the Cheerleaders are in fact Cheerleaders. And I believe they are Masons, aren't scum the ultimate form of Masons. Now that doesn't tell us whether they are town or scum. I even had the crazy thought that Trenton could be aligned with the cheerleaders and that all this fighting back and forth is so if we vote one of them, find them scum, we trust the opposition to our downfall the next day. So many possibilities.

It's funny because I entered the day thinking Trentonlf, Budejovice and Sage were my prime scum combination, the cheerleaders, while possible, weren't my first choice. Now, they are on at least equal footing and primarily because of the way Flub was pushing people to vote.

If we take everyone claim to be true than we have..

1) Sage103082 - Candy Striper (Town Doctor)
2) mrkgnao - Cheerleader (Mason)
3) dedoporno - Nerd - Town Vigilante.
4) trentonlf - Teacher's Pet - Bulletproof
5) JMich -- Hippie (Town Lover) left school Day 1
6) CSPVG -- Student Body President (Town Double-Voter) expelled Day 2
7) HijacK -- Goth (Town Lover) expelled Day 1
8) budejovice - Wide-receiver (Town Flavor-Cop)
9) adaliabooks -- Newspaper Editor (Town Watcher) sent to the hospital Night 2
10) flubbucket - Cheerleader (Mason)
11) Robbeasy -- Hall Monitor (Town Cop) sent to the hospital Night 1
12) QuadrAlien/RWarehall - Upperclassman - Jailkeeper

So that leaves us with the Principal. Is he tired of our shit after four long year and decided to get his revenge by turning us against each other?

Doubtful.

Well, this is how the principal thinks of you in his nightmares. He is also deathly afraid of breakaway walls and windows. Alas, to date, he has not killed any students. The man is a prince among men ... a saint, truth be told.

Also, this is another one of his nightmares. It is actually the one I should have listed earlier (seems more appropriate). Add breakaway floors and ceilings to his list of fears.

Thank you.. this will be going through my head over and over tonight when I am trying to shut it up and go to sleep. =)