Welcome Zchinque!! almost like you planned it ;o)

If you ain't been following then I urge you to read the whole thread - even early on day one theres stuff you should really be taking in, instead of just todays shenanigans!

Don't worry, we can wait...!

Thats good news, I was hoping that Zchnique got a chance in here after being killed in the other one. Now I just hope that Cruward was indeed just noobish, and not a scum. I would like his (Zchnique's) analytic mind for town.

I was doing my New Year's catching up on the thread a few days ago when I ran into post #1020. I thought "Woah, I'll tackle that tomorrow!". When the next day came there were even more posts and I felt too busy to catch up at that point and so it all spiralled out of control. I'm here now though!

So, I still don't really trust Red_Baron on his quote/paraphrase thing but that in itself isn't scummy so I'll just keep an eye on him for now.

I think that Rob is acting kind of weird, so since he's only on 2 votes at the moment I don't feel there's too much danger in putting a bit more pressure on him: vote Robbeasy

Why, thank you!

....wait, planned what exactly? Oh, I'll read the whole thread, don't worry about that. I'll read it, take some notes*, and then probably make a huge post which people will lambast for being "veiled in secrecy" or somesuch.

*Note: Some of you might read Game #10 (some of you are in Game #10, so I hope you read it) and no, this is not me claiming scum. I do take notes when I need to catch up on a thousand posts. I'm sure at least you can, seeing as you seem to be under a bit of pressure right now... ;)

Why, you're in luck, I can shine some light on the issue. Indeed, I have Cruward's alignment right here in front of me - mod confirmed, no less!

Indeed - it would be nice if the pressure was actually for any concrete reason I could answer...

Actually, there is a point I would like to make - why do I keep getting lambasted for coming up with what is the most logical choice for lynch? Yes Rod tuned up town, but I think everyone knows it gave us more information to work with than ANY other lynch would have done.

All I have done is look at whats happened today and made the same conclusions - how anyone can see that as scummy is beyond me.

You say its wrong reasoning - explain to me how lynching a lurker gives us more information to work with. There are many sorts of scum - in my (very) limited experience you might get one quiet one in a team, but more likely there will be *just* enough posts to not be put in the 'lurker' pot, or copious amounts of posts. Especially on this forum, where we seem to be very sharp on lynching lurkers!

I'm all for lynching a lurker if there is no better target - i just feel that in this case, there is.

But I want to focus on SirPrimalForm for now, and for this...

You're happy to push me, but...'hey everyone! Im definitely town look, because i qualify it because he's not got many votes yet'!

You dont want to be seen doing anything that might in the future be leapt on - so you're making sure your excuse for putting pressure on me is front and centre at the earliest opportunity. You dont even have any real reason for voting, just 'acting kinda wierd'.

I think you're reading into it a bit much there. I meant what I said, you're in no real danger at the moment so I see no problem in using my vote to poke you.
Think of it as a slightly more meaningful FOS.

HaHa, doesn't really say anything . But I would be surprised if it did, since I would deem that an odd reaction to my post. So even if you have it with mod confirmation HeHe, I don't want to know it. But yea, as Robb said a lot of reading to catch up to and odd discussions. Most my day ingame today have been spent trying to get the info out that no night kill by mafia took place and that I have this knowledge because I killed Vitek. And then answering as to why I revealed this knowledge and discussions about wording of sentences. Thats about it.

No, I don't agree with all of them, which is why I say "many" and I do plan to outline the reasons why when I get more of a chance, which isn't now. I was out all day and am currently rather tired, so more of something constructive after I wake up.

I just started going back and rereading posts for my read on what Rodzaju did, but I'm wondering if anyone who has gone back and done rereads noticed this. Post 20 was edited almost a month after it was made.

I think the only addition is

2JSA the post was made on Oct 29th, and edited on the 25th of November. I just figured I'd bring this up, since it strikes me as odd.

Cheaty breadcrumbing?

Just went through the thread to see what was going on on 25/11/11 and here's the only post Rod made that day: http://www.gog.com/en/forum/general/gog_forum_mafia_9/post632

It's been 11 minutes, fingers crossed this doesn't merge.

So nothing that gives a hint...oh well, guess we won't be able to find out til after the game...gonna bother me now.

Analysis post probably later today/tomorrow as it's pretty late now.

Welcome, Z. This day started in #814, but you have probably found that out already.
It is my opinion that this forums does lynching lurkers all wrong.
I remember once before Rodzaju made a mafia giveaway -- he hid four pieces of a gift code in games he had played. That's what this is. Shouldn't have been messing with a game in progress, but it's harmless enough.

Ahhhhh, ok, forgot all about that. Bah, now I feel dumb.

Im on a train on the phone so...

day 1 4
day 2 472
day 3 814

That, I allowed him to hide a piece of code into a post as part of a giveaway he was doing