It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
If yesterday had happened differently and Pazzer hadn't been lynched - the deadline had passed and I hadn't voted for him - then I would be humbly accepting of you guys calling me out as you are.
That didn't happen though so spthh to you. :-p
avatar
JoeSapphire: If yesterday had happened differently and Pazzer hadn't been lynched - the deadline had passed and I hadn't voted for him - then I would be humbly accepting of you guys calling me out as you are.
That didn't happen though so spthh to you. :-p
I wasn't able to see if you are online or not. Were you still around when Robbeasy hammered?
avatar
JoeSapphire: If yesterday had happened differently and Pazzer hadn't been lynched - the deadline had passed and I hadn't voted for him - then I would be humbly accepting of you guys calling me out as you are.
That didn't happen though so spthh to you. :-p
There's a difference, you claimed he's a Liar. By Lynch all Liars there is only ONE course of action that makes sense, especially if you can prove it.

Vote JoeSapphire
avatar
JoeSapphire: If yesterday had happened differently and Pazzer hadn't been lynched - the deadline had passed and I hadn't voted for him - then I would be humbly accepting of you guys calling me out as you are.
That didn't happen though so spthh to you. :-p
Fair point, but you posted your info less than an hour (presumably, GOG's timestamps have misled me) before the deadline, and it did pass without you voting for him. In fact, if there hadn't been a last minute extension we would have had a nolynch, and you would not have voted on it. There's no way you could have known about an extension.

Not saying this is a scumtell. I am saying it is a really odd and unusual play, and I can't figure out how it benefits scum or town.

(Also minor clarification. My last agreed was directed at getting Pazzer lynched, not at agreeing that Joe is town. I'm still pretty neutral on that one)
avatar
Vitek: I wasn't able to see if you are online or not. Were you still around when Robbeasy hammered?
not actually when he hammered - I was walking up a big hill - but I was came back in between the hammer and the supposed deadline. I damned his head?
Whoops, got my fact wrong. Joe made his Pazzer=liar post 80-120 minutes before the deadline, not an hour before.
Unvote.
avatar
JoeSapphire: If yesterday had happened differently and Pazzer hadn't been lynched - the deadline had passed and I hadn't voted for him - then I would be humbly accepting of you guys calling me out as you are.
That didn't happen though so spthh to you. :-p
avatar
TwilightBard: There's a difference, you claimed he's a Liar. By Lynch all Liars there is only ONE course of action that makes sense, especially if you can prove it.

Vote JoeSapphire
I could achieve the lynch without immediately voting though. In fact I think I did. Vitek as proposing lynching Rob - you proposed lynching yourself for some reason - I could see the danger of everybody moving off pazzer's wagon and onto another so I said what I had to say.
And I took on the responsibility to hang around until the end.

spthh I say! spttttthhhhhhhhhh
avatar
JoeSapphire: [blahblah]If you had to name 3 or 4 mafia now who would you name?
avatar
jefequeso: Well, obviously Zchnique. Apart from him, I'm not completely certain. Crazybear set off my alarm bells for his immediately defensive...erm...defense :P. And I guess Stuart also, for pushing Crazybear so hard, although I suppose that's what everyone is doing.

At this point I'm not certain. I sort of like staying back and watching how things develop at the early stage (as I did in Game 9).
Hey! check it out!
Now do we think that, knowing the mafia as he did, he would name three non-mafia or he would sprinkle a few mafia names in there? We know that two named are town. What about number three?

((yeah I started reading through. I'm kinda just skimming the beginning at the moment))
avatar
JoeSapphire: I could achieve the lynch without immediately voting though. In fact I think I did. Vitek as proposing lynching Rob - you proposed lynching yourself for some reason - I could see the danger of everybody moving off pazzer's wagon and onto another so I said what I had to say.
And I took on the responsibility to hang around until the end.

spthh I say! spttttthhhhhhhhhh
He claimed watcher. You just don't go and lynch claimed watcher without considering other options. Well, amybe you do but I don't. Of course, saying what you said was only correct and it earned you a lot of town points, I am not doubting it. It's strange that you didn't vote him as he wasn't at L-1 at that moment, right? You could have asked people not to hammer him until he has chance to show up but voting him when you catch him lying about his claim should be standard procedure.

About pazzer connection... I don't think post like this can be useful on it's own. You would have to find they are connected more than this as this can be easily down-played as WIFOM any time. It will be hard to find something condemning until there is something obvious (as Peanut defending Stuart, Itai muttly etc.).
If there were 2 scums identified it would be quite possible to find connection to third but this way I expect it to be too hard. You should keep trying, though. ;-)
Wow, I am alive... Feels good! I was also blocked (or something) last night. I dont have time to comment right now but wanted to let everyone know. I have several thoughts on the starting comments of D4, but will have to get to them later.
Another roleblock? I smell something fishy. There seem to be a lot of PR's. A bit too much. Joe, muttly, unknown RB, Zchinque, bureaucrat. Is there another known PR I forgot?
Anyone with any ideas on how Muttly survived another night then? As self claimed cop and with the Doc dead, I would have thought he was one dead duck.
Jailer I guess. Or he is scum.
What flavour you got muttly?
I imagine it was something like this. Joe was roleblocked by mafia as they knew he has some power. Muttly was bigger threat so they tried to kill him. Town has jailer and he decided to protect muttly even if it denied his ability.
All this and previous options give us this these reads:
Almost comfirmed towns
Vítek - copped and helped to get pazzer
JoeSapphire - caught pazzer lying and was blocked by scum
muttly - cop who was likely targeted by scum

Scum pool:
Twilight
Peanut
Robbeasy
stuart
itai

Among these should be 2 remaining scums. My narrower pool would be stuart, Rob and itai.

There is possibility that it's something else (as lying muttly or intentionally skipped NK) but this is most likely, IMO.