PlanesWalker1337: I've always been annoyed by Gothic fans saying Gothic 3 is a bad game.
Well, as a Gothic fan since 2000, I can say that Gothic 3 *was* a bad game. The initial release was an absolute, almost unplayable unfinished mess. In the followiing years, though, the community fixed many of those issues (both with the immense patch and with mods), so now everyone could safely say that Gothic 3 is a good game.
So widely different from the previous two that if it had another title nobody would notice that it is part of the series, but still objectively fine.
Imo, it does exactly what The Elder Scrolls do, only in a much, much more charismatic way. I always found -please, don't hate me for this- TES games very shallow, and G3 presents a similar kind of gameplay in a much better designed, more interesting and "living" world. The fact that Pirhanha Bytes always scripted the behaviour of every single NPC to give it a believable daily routine and hand-crafted even the smallest particulars of each map adds much to this.