Posted June 15, 2020
A little bit of necro, but this is one of the most inspiring thread on gog, and I always wanted to do something in this matter.
So I sent some e-mails lately, regarding some old games that we're still missing here (and in other places).
Right now I have not much to report.
1) Return of the Phantom. It's the game that was created by Microprose/MPS Labs, just like Rex Nebular and Dragonsphere. So it should be already here, but it's like everyone forgot about it.
I received the answer from Tommo/Retroism that they don't have rights to Return of the Phantom.
It wasn't a part of bankruptcy sale. http://docs.bmcgroup.com/Atari/nysb_1-13-bk-10176_313.pdf
Recently I noticed that on Atari page on wikipedia there's a whole part about the games that Atari still have rights to. "As of 2018, Atari, SA own the rights to the following games and game franchises. The majority of these are original works by Atari, Hasbro Interactive or Infogrames, however the most notable outside of these are a large number of intellectual properties formerly belonging to Ocean Software, which Atari never lost the rights. " Some of those games are now on GOG through Ziggurat Interactive - for example soem games from Legend Entertainment.
It's possible that Atari still have rights to Return of the Phantom, as they were not a part of bankruptcy sale.
But reading through the Purchase Agreement between Atari, Inc. and Rebellion Developments, Stardock & Tommo provides some more info.
First of all, some games were marked as: "The following are Microprose titles which do not appear on the Hasbro acquisition schedule. However, it is possible that these titles did not appear on the schedule because they do not have corresponding copyright registrations, and as a result may have inadvertently been left off the schedule"
It could mean that some Microprose games were not Atari asset before the bankruptcy sale and so Return of the Phantom could be still somewhere else, but that remark was also added to 7th Legion, which is already on GOG.
I haven't read any documents other than Purchase Agreement between Atari, Inc. and Rebellion Developments, Stardock & Tommo so it's rather a guess from my side, but I think there's a chance that Return of the Phantom was omitted by mistake during bankruptcy sale, and the rights are still with Atari. There's no logical reason that this game could have shared a different fate than Rex Nebular or Dragonsphere.
I'm going to write to Atari about that.
And by the way, if wikipedia is right about Atari rights regarding Legend Entertainment games, then Atari still have rights to Gateway and The Wheel of Time. These two games are based on 3rd party IP, Frederik Pohl and Robert Jordan respectively, both deceased, so it's very possible that the release of these games would require the agreement to IP holders (I think that RObert Jordan's IP belongs to his wife, she asked Brandon Sanderson to finish The Wheel of Time series). We had Death Gate from Legend Entertainent on GOG for a moment but it disappeard quickly because of the rights, so it's possible that Atari has rights to those games but cannot sell them anymore (same for Companions of Xanth and Shannara). In the end I think GOG would have to approach IP holders and ask them to make a deal the way they did with Blade Runner - that has to be a three party deal.
Oh, and I know that someone is in talks with GOG to bring their old games here. I won't share who before/if they will show up, but that will be very nice addition to the catalogue.
So I sent some e-mails lately, regarding some old games that we're still missing here (and in other places).
Right now I have not much to report.
1) Return of the Phantom. It's the game that was created by Microprose/MPS Labs, just like Rex Nebular and Dragonsphere. So it should be already here, but it's like everyone forgot about it.
I received the answer from Tommo/Retroism that they don't have rights to Return of the Phantom.
It wasn't a part of bankruptcy sale. http://docs.bmcgroup.com/Atari/nysb_1-13-bk-10176_313.pdf
Recently I noticed that on Atari page on wikipedia there's a whole part about the games that Atari still have rights to. "As of 2018, Atari, SA own the rights to the following games and game franchises. The majority of these are original works by Atari, Hasbro Interactive or Infogrames, however the most notable outside of these are a large number of intellectual properties formerly belonging to Ocean Software, which Atari never lost the rights. " Some of those games are now on GOG through Ziggurat Interactive - for example soem games from Legend Entertainment.
It's possible that Atari still have rights to Return of the Phantom, as they were not a part of bankruptcy sale.
But reading through the Purchase Agreement between Atari, Inc. and Rebellion Developments, Stardock & Tommo provides some more info.
First of all, some games were marked as: "The following are Microprose titles which do not appear on the Hasbro acquisition schedule. However, it is possible that these titles did not appear on the schedule because they do not have corresponding copyright registrations, and as a result may have inadvertently been left off the schedule"
It could mean that some Microprose games were not Atari asset before the bankruptcy sale and so Return of the Phantom could be still somewhere else, but that remark was also added to 7th Legion, which is already on GOG.
I haven't read any documents other than Purchase Agreement between Atari, Inc. and Rebellion Developments, Stardock & Tommo so it's rather a guess from my side, but I think there's a chance that Return of the Phantom was omitted by mistake during bankruptcy sale, and the rights are still with Atari. There's no logical reason that this game could have shared a different fate than Rex Nebular or Dragonsphere.
I'm going to write to Atari about that.
And by the way, if wikipedia is right about Atari rights regarding Legend Entertainment games, then Atari still have rights to Gateway and The Wheel of Time. These two games are based on 3rd party IP, Frederik Pohl and Robert Jordan respectively, both deceased, so it's very possible that the release of these games would require the agreement to IP holders (I think that RObert Jordan's IP belongs to his wife, she asked Brandon Sanderson to finish The Wheel of Time series). We had Death Gate from Legend Entertainent on GOG for a moment but it disappeard quickly because of the rights, so it's possible that Atari has rights to those games but cannot sell them anymore (same for Companions of Xanth and Shannara). In the end I think GOG would have to approach IP holders and ask them to make a deal the way they did with Blade Runner - that has to be a three party deal.
Oh, and I know that someone is in talks with GOG to bring their old games here. I won't share who before/if they will show up, but that will be very nice addition to the catalogue.