Telika: A certain brand of ironical distanciation allows us to have the cake and eat it too. To enjoy it with a "yeah yeah, I know, but, still...". And I think this is what WH40000 and Starship Troopers aim for (and achieve). Not simply denouncing one kind of narrative, but allowing us to indulge in it
with an ironical dissociation. While poking fun at
ourselves for enjoying it.
Well worded. Personally, I see no problem with cheering for Rico when he grenades the fat bug and at the same time laughing at him for being so inane to be in the mobile infantry. Infantry is absolutely crucial (both RL and for capturing brain bugs) but no one in their right mind wants to do that if there is any other choice, at all. I remember carefully studying the Swiss Army brochure and choosing the job that seemed most removed from infantry because everyone from my Alpine village was sent straight to mountain infantry if they didn't have a plan. 7 other people wanted the same job that I wanted but I studied the brochure more carefully and figured out how to play the cards properly so I got the job. I wasn't in any way better qualified than the other people, I just figured out the system. Fuck you, Klendathu!
Telika: It is a subtle-ish position, and as such, I'm not sure I manage to express it clearly. Another way to describe it is maybe through the 'hommage' angle (hommage to a genre, or to an epoch in individual lives). It reminds me of a
leftist friend who adores Conan the Barbarian, and describes it as an openly
fascist pleasure, enjoyable precisely because of its clear shameless relaxing fascist undertones.
I find it amazing how completely and utterly unaware left wingers are to the fact that fascism is fascism and that left wing fascism is 100,00% as bad as right wing fascism - the only difference being that left-wing fascism has resulted in even more dead people so far. The majority of intolerant, close-minded, illogical, nasty, self-righteous, smug, hypocritical, egotistical and hateful people I've met were not right-wingers but
left wingers. In theory, both are supposed to be equally unreasonable but the level of self-awareness is generally lower in leftists. They have a stronger tendency to believe they're the good guys and not many things are more dangerous than that. Being right wing is equaled with being evil nowadays and as a result I have not met a single person who said they were right-wingers, on the other hand I've met plenty of people who proudly call themselves leftists or even far leftist - both in RL and on the internet, including this forum. As if that was anything good.
I was once again too cynical to vote in the county council elections last weekend but if I had to vote for someone, I would happily choose the right-wing Swiss People's Party (SVP/UDC), just to piss off all my leftist colleagues and acquaintances. Due t silly and petty partisan mentality, they would never in a hundred years vote for anything the SVP/UDC supports, regardless of the issue at hand. Most of the left-wingers I know aren't technically dumb at all which makes things even worse because lack of intelligence would at least partially excuse them. Just can't take their smug attitudes and immunity to reason anymore. Have been neutral most of my life but I'm done with that. It's sad how the polarization of the political landscape can make the most neutral-minded person unable to maintain their position. Debate gets you nowhere, it's a waste of precious energy with no results. So next election, I'm voting for the right wing - it will be the first time I ever support any side in council elections. In terms of nation-wide popular votes on specific issues, I'm already on the right-wing side anyway (anti-EU etc). Despite cynicism, I still have some minimal self preservation instinct. Something a shocking number of people don't have.
/ off-topic miffed political rant, sorry had to but not sorry for my opinion!
Telika: Maybe the "meta" movies oif Tarantino play a bit with this too : is Kill Bill a parody of saber revenge flicks, or is it one itself, or is it both.
Probably depends on how familiar one is with the material he's ripping/riffing off from. Tarantino is more like a DJ/VJ to me rather than an original filmmaker. Either way, imho Tarantino fails both in the fight and comedy category. No amount of clever camera work can hide the fact that Uma Thurman doesn't have the necessary skill to make the fights have enough "oomph" and the comedy isn't nearly as funny as a proper Hong Kong action comedy. Personally, I'm getting more entertainment from watching a good old Jackie Chan movie.
This video explains the point I'm trying to make in detail:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z1PCtIaM_GQ Telika: How would someone make an enjoyable cheezy spaggheti westen nowadays, without making it as accidentally bad as all these clumsy post-Leone copies, yet capturing their flavor and interest for people who outgrew them, that its, without turning them into a comedy ?
Exactly - they can't. It's either going to be a grimdark wannabe badass remake or a parody = "we don't have the balls or skill to make something proper and we're too afraid hipsters will make fun of it if we try for real."