NoNewTaleToTell: What about the first moderators? (Or modiraters?).
In my opinion, leave the mods out**, it rarely ends well. Of course it would be nice to have somebody who has been given the task of eliminating forum spam***, but that would be it. Although not perfect, the community does balance itself out more or less and is generally one of the best communities around.
**Unless GOG wants to hire me, then it's a good idea.
***Speaking of which, hey GOG I'm available if you need that spot filled!
I'll work cheap!
tinyE: My problem isn't the idea, it's the a-typical result. SPAM is one thing but there are so many judgement calls to be made and I don't want some uptight asshole showing up and telling me I can't post my mouse necro pic. I remember the 1st time I ever used IRC; the Mods were 'supposed' to be rational but inevitably turds showed up who started chucking out anyone that didn't emulate Mr. Rogers or Bob Ross.
Oh it might be fine for a while but one day I'd show up and tell someone (probably a friend) that they are full of shit, and POW I'd get kicked.
Oh I understand, and to look at it from a slightly different perspective, I've been a mod on a fairly large forum before and it's not all fun. If you're too lax then people complain about you not doing your job, if you're strict then you're powertripping according to some, not to mention having to untangle fights haha.
Now that was just a fan forum for a band, I'd hate to mod for a store** since every action you take would be a reflection (in the eyes of some people anyway) of the store.
**Except for you GOG, I would love to mod your forums! You've still got my resume somewhere, come on, get on it!