Fallout

You're on a roll tonight. :P

Interplay's The Lord of the Rings Volume 3: The Return of the King
Leisure Suit Larry 4
Babylon 5: Into the Fire
Space Quest 6 Demo
Space Quest VII: Return to Roman Numerals
Ultima VIII: The Lost Vale

Prey 2

How about the game that was originally given the title Quake, before it morphed into something very different? Namely, the one that would have been in a fantasy medieval setting with RPG elements and dragons.

Also, why is the original post "low rated"? It really makes it hard for those interested in the thread to follow it.

Most likely due to people assuming this is a bait thread, due to the OP's game choice.

Haha too true man.
To.. tru.. *sob*

Yes, I agree...even though those LotR games were flawed (though admittedly I only played them many years after their release which may have affected my judgement), it's pretty sad the third part was never made. Would have been great if you could have replayed all of the LotR story.

Serial Killer Roguelike

It sounded like an interesting idea, but unfortunately it was just a hoax.

Command and Conquer Generals 2.

i never knew there was a v II

im only familar with the snes version

There was a 2nd part ("The two towers")...somewhat flawed like the first one (and shorter), but actually kind of fun...if I remember correctly, you switched between the different groups (Aragorn, Legolas, Gimli; Sam and Frodo...can't remember if Merry and Pepin got their own content). Got it a few years ago on some abandonware site.
Would be nice if these games came to Gog.

Gonna be seconding a lot of titles here:

Prey 2
Stalker 2
NOLF 3
Bloodlines 2

As for my own personal nominations:

Syndicate 3

X-Com Apocalypse 2

they'd have to hash it out with interplay ( whats left of them ) the original creators and publishers of the games
EA the current game license holders ( but just the movies mind you which is why all their games take place during the movies )
and the estate of tolkien

i honestly dont see it happening

Castlevania Symphony of the night 2

Edit: Yeah.. I know.. somebody else try and make me see out. ^^