Posted August 03, 2015
Sage103082
Kitten Tamer: 8
Registered: Mar 2014
From United States
flubbucket
"Intoning"
Registered: Dec 2012
From Micronesia
Bookwyrm627
ADD Jumping Bean
Registered: Nov 2013
From United States
Posted August 03, 2015
I enjoyed the game, as far as I managed to play and then watching it after being evicted. I admit I didn't worry about rereading or closely analyzing players (and I'm blaming that for Yog fooling me, and totally definitely wasn't his skill or anythinglikethatsothere), so some of the nuance might be lost on me.
One thing about player critique: You might consider doing it via PM rather than in the open, and might consider waiting for them to ask. Avoids potential embarrassment, and hopefully removes any potential ego related issues.
As for the game, it was an interesting setup, and the only ill advised part was having a town aligned player needing to protect the SK. I'm already too biased by having been in the dead thread as long as I was (and as early), so I can't say for sure whether I'd have bought into a town arsonist. I'm not sure the "basic win conditions may have extra criteria" bit was emphasized enough for a townie to be protecting SK. The rest (beyond the mod errors, which have already been discussed and acknowledged) seems more or less fine to me.
Sadly, I'm not sure what the flavor is a reference to, beyond what was already stated in the dead thread.
One thing about player critique: You might consider doing it via PM rather than in the open, and might consider waiting for them to ask. Avoids potential embarrassment, and hopefully removes any potential ego related issues.
As for the game, it was an interesting setup, and the only ill advised part was having a town aligned player needing to protect the SK. I'm already too biased by having been in the dead thread as long as I was (and as early), so I can't say for sure whether I'd have bought into a town arsonist. I'm not sure the "basic win conditions may have extra criteria" bit was emphasized enough for a townie to be protecting SK. The rest (beyond the mod errors, which have already been discussed and acknowledged) seems more or less fine to me.
Sadly, I'm not sure what the flavor is a reference to, beyond what was already stated in the dead thread.
flubbucket
"Intoning"
Registered: Dec 2012
From Micronesia
Posted August 05, 2015
test
nothing to see here
nothing to see here
Post edited August 05, 2015 by flubbucket
JMich
A Horrible Human Person. If you need me, chat.
Registered: Apr 2011
From Greece
flubbucket
"Intoning"
Registered: Dec 2012
From Micronesia
