It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
Lost a post to GOG, trying to redo...

LOLChan's playstyle is hard for me to read. One moment he acts like he doesn't know what he's doing and the next moment he drops a good post. Still, I think if he gives more of his opinions his alignment willl be easier to determine.

Right now though, after reading SPF's and LOLChan's posts, paired with some suspicions of my own, I think Nmillar is the most likely to be scum.
Vote Nmillar
avatar
SirPrimalform: I'm leaning slightly towards nmillar being scum. Something about the way he joined the wagons.

avatar
nmillar: Whoa! Just saw agent's "I was scum, now I'm town" post. Unvote SPF, vote agentcarr.
avatar
SirPrimalform: With agentcarr there's a feeling of "My buddies are bussing each other. Whoops, better pick a side quickly!

avatar
nmillar: Yeah, somehow managed to scroll past that on my phone! My bad ...

vote trent
avatar
SirPrimalform: With Trent's wagon, nmillar was theoretically in favour of lynching Trent earlier on but seemed to spend a long time stalling before eventually hammering. Once the lynch seems inevitable you've got to make sure you're on the wagon!

It's not much, but it feels like something. Anyone got any thoughts on my thoughts?
There were some oddities in nmillar's behavior, I admit, but then he did point out that GameRager offing gogtrial would've been to obvious.
avatar
SirPrimalform: I'm leaning slightly towards nmillar being scum. Something about the way he joined the wagons.

With agentcarr there's a feeling of "My buddies are bussing each other. Whoops, better pick a side quickly!

With Trent's wagon, nmillar was theoretically in favour of lynching Trent earlier on but seemed to spend a long time stalling before eventually hammering. Once the lynch seems inevitable you've got to make sure you're on the wagon!

It's not much, but it feels like something. Anyone got any thoughts on my thoughts?
avatar
blotunga: There were some oddities in nmillar's behavior, I admit, but then he did point out that GameRager offing gogtrial would've been to obvious.
I was also the first to confirm that GameRager is definitely town!

I get that my delaying on day 2 can be seen as somewhat scummy behaviour, but it is only my second game back from a long absence, so part of me doesn't want the game to finish too quickly.

I'm not 100% convinced that the Mason role clears GameRager and blotunga, as we've seen in previous games that they do not necessarily have the same alignment, especially considering blotunga's caginess when prodded about it.

It will be interesting to see where the game develops from here, but for now the main suspects for me are LOLchan and Pooka. RFG isnt in the clear yet, but I'm more suspicious of the other two.
avatar
nmillar: I'm not 100% convinced that the Mason role clears GameRager and blotunga, as we've seen in previous games that they do not necessarily have the same alignment, especially considering blotunga's caginess when prodded about it.
Have we seen that? Then they wouldn't be Masons, they would just be Neighbors - and Neighbors usually have a chat and aren't told each other's alignment. I agree that blotunga seemed evasive when prodded for details, which looked strange. So let's sort this out:

@GameRager: were you explicitly told by the mod, that blotunga is Town (Haitian)? If so, why did you speculate about his scumminess?
avatar
GameRager: Either blotunga is scum and is claiming a PR to clear me and clear himself in the process, or it's someone else entirely.
Was that just for distraction, to not reveal that you knew more? Or were you actually unsure at that point? If you actually were unsure because you never got the mod-confirmation, then the theory that blotunga cleared himself by using a non-standard Neighbor-like connection to clear you is still a possibility.
avatar
GameRager: Either blotunga is scum and is claiming a PR to clear me and clear himself in the process, or it's someone else entirely.
avatar
Lifthrasil: Was that just for distraction, to not reveal that you knew more? Or were you actually unsure at that point? If you actually were unsure because you never got the mod-confirmation, then the theory that blotunga cleared himself by using a non-standard Neighbor-like connection to clear you is still a possibility.
Good catch!
avatar
Lifthrasil: Have we seen that? Then they wouldn't be Masons, they would just be Neighbors - and Neighbors usually have a chat and aren't told each other's alignment. I agree that blotunga seemed evasive when prodded for details, which looked strange. So let's sort this out:

@GameRager: were you explicitly told by the mod, that blotunga is Town (Haitian)? If so, why did you speculate about his scumminess?
Was that just for distraction, to not reveal that you knew more? Or were you actually unsure at that point? If you actually were unsure because you never got the mod-confirmation, then the theory that blotunga cleared himself by using a non-standard Neighbor-like connection to clear you is still a possibility.
It's not. I was told in the PM that I'm Haitian Mason, and that GameRager is also Haitian Mason
VOTE COUNT:

1 - nmillar --- RedFireGaming,

0 - Blotunga ---
0 - GameRager ---
0 - RedFireGaming
0 - SirPrimalform
0 - LOLchan
0 - Lifthrasil
0 - PookaMustard

Not Voting: Blotunga, LOLchan, GameRager, nmillar, Lifthrasil, PookaMustard, SirPrimalform,

nmillar is closest to elimination at 4 votes from majority.
avatar
blotunga: It's not. I was told in the PM that I'm Haitian Mason, and that GameRager is also Haitian Mason
I wasn't asking you. I was asking GR for confirmation of what you wrote. You can't confirm yourself, you know? Please don't try to put words in GR's mouth but let him speak for himself!
avatar
SirPrimalform: With Trent's wagon, nmillar was theoretically in favour of lynching Trent earlier on but seemed to spend a long time stalling before eventually hammering. Once the lynch seems inevitable you've got to make sure you're on the wagon!

It's not much, but it feels like something. Anyone got any thoughts on my thoughts?
avatar
LOLChan: Nmillar wanted to slow down the vote.(that's for certain) But it also seems that nmillar was on with trents lynch. Not sure if that’s just a tactic not to appear suspicious.
I did in fact note that, and yes being on the lynch of scum is absolutely something an experienced player (like nmillar) would know to do.

avatar
blotunga: It's not. I was told in the PM that I'm Haitian Mason, and that GameRager is also Haitian Mason
Oh, I didn't realise your name was also GameRager!
deadline saturdayish
deadline pooka

Am I doing it right?
avatar
SirPrimalform: deadline pooka

Am I doing it right?
When the profile pic of the user is feminine, you use the form "deadlane", as in Deadlane LOLChan
avatar
SirPrimalform: an experienced player (like nmillar)
Aww, you!
avatar
SirPrimalform: an experienced player (like nmillar)
avatar
nmillar: Aww, you!
We are immortalised in the GOG ruleset, that makes us the most experienced!
avatar
nmillar: I'm not 100% convinced that the Mason role clears GameRager and blotunga, as we've seen in previous games that they do not necessarily have the same alignment, especially considering blotunga's caginess when prodded about it.
avatar
Lifthrasil: Have we seen that? Then they wouldn't be Masons, they would just be Neighbors - and Neighbors usually have a chat and aren't told each other's alignment. I agree that blotunga seemed evasive when prodded for details, which looked strange. So let's sort this out:

@GameRager: were you explicitly told by the mod, that blotunga is Town (Haitian)? If so, why did you speculate about his scumminess?
--------------------------------------------
avatar
GameRager: Either blotunga is scum and is claiming a PR to clear me and clear himself in the process, or it's someone else entirely.
avatar
Lifthrasil: Was that just for distraction, to not reveal that you knew more? Or were you actually unsure at that point? If you actually were unsure because you never got the mod-confirmation, then the theory that blotunga cleared himself by using a non-standard Neighbor-like connection to clear you is still a possibility.
1st bit: It says as blotunga said before I posted this reply(likely to help me out as I do not get online quickly sometimes).....he is Haitian Mason as well, although I now don't think we have chat(due to a blundered PM to blotunga instead of asking Joe first if we had chat like I should have done), but I could be wrong(would have to ask joe about if we have chat or not to be 100% sure).

2nd bit: I believe at the time I was still unsure what the mason bit on my game PM meant/how he was related to me, but then after the end of "day 2"(the one where trent was lynched) & while making my last reply for that "day" I figured it out due to blotunga's posts/other people's posts made before that "day" ended& also by going back and re-reading the role PM.
=================================
avatar
SirPrimalform: deadline pooka

Am I doing it right?
Is this a vote written a silly way?
=================================

avatar
RedFireGaming: When the profile pic of the user is feminine, you use the form "deadlane", as in Deadlane LOLChan
Same question as I just asked SPF....this a vote?