argamasa: I agree itch.io is the worst, not only front page, the way you manage your library and games owned.
Yeah, I remember the time they had that charity sale with like 1700 games or something, and I bought it, and then I had to figure out where they all went, as they weren't with my regular purchases. Figuring out their site is like a little game in itself!
EDIT: On the other hand, it turns out I was kind of glad they weren't just thrown in with my regular purchases, as I did want to keep those separate.
Time4Tea: I think GOG's landing page is ok. It's far from the worst store front page I have seen. OP: you say you don't like it, but how would you improve it?
I know you weren't addressing me, but:
I'd like a darker theme available for nighttime viewing. Other than that, I really don't have a big problem with it other than maybe it's trying to do a little too much on that one page.
Imo, the biggest issue is that the GOG front page barely does anything to advertise their one biggest selling point - that their games are DRM-free. It is barely mentioned anywhere, yet it should be front and center! It's what the whole store is about, after all.
That's a good point. GOG needs to keep in mind that there are always new young people getting into gaming that may not already know everything we old-timers take for granted.