FrodoBaggins: The Mysteries of Cow Island is an adventure game in the style of Sam and Max and Monkey Island -- wacky, warped, and a joy to play
The title alone caught my interest. The world NEEDS more P&C adventure games like Monkey Island, Sam & Max, and Maniac Mansion. ( :
The title alone made me lose interest. They can't possibly be even halfway as good as Monkey Island, so they should come up with something more original. Of course, this could be a parody, but how is a parody of a comedy going to be like?
It really doesn't help that they don't show any pictures (WIP, concept, or others) of the game and their KS page doesn't even have a video. In fact, even their text description doesn't mention what exact genre this is supposed to be, what kind of graphical style it is supposed to have, or give even the most simple hint of plot setting.
And of course, their description really doesn't make much sense otherwise either. First they say "We plan to fill this gap with a genuine retelling of 80's computing", but later they say "[AGS] is free, and it can do 1990s adventure games very, very well". So which is it? Are they trying to recreate the 80s or 90s adventure style?
I would be very cautious to back this one. Projects with much, much more detailed plans have failed, and these guys don't even seem to have any plans at all.
I hope to be proven wrong here.