rjbuffchix: If someone like me is primarily boycotting because of what I view as increasing DRM, then people okay with increasing DRM or some DRM or DRM-lite etc are not really helping my particular cause.
GamezRanker: But how do you know they're not helping(or even harming) the cause, other than your gut feeling?
Also(if I may say so), you
seem to focus more on how others are "harming" the cause, and less on ways you could help the cause better. For instance, complaining here on Gog forums isn't as effective as complaining on other sites would be(as shown in the case of the Hitman GOTY removal, which happened in large part due to people complaining on other sites).
I mean yes, one doesn't have to do things they don't want to, but to hear you talk so passionately about the cause of DRM free and then stick to mainly posting on the Gog forums....do you see what i'm getting at, here?
You make good points. I'm not sure if the last sentence is meant as rhetorical but will try to address all of what you bring up.
First, there isn't absolute certainty with such situations since we can't know the future or what specifically caused it. I would say my opinion is based on a mix of intuition, historical background, and logic. The intuition part is like you said, gut feeling. The historical background part is that in similar cases previously, the acceptance of DRM has reduced the space for DRM-free. We can also look at other non-gaming examples where rental has replaced ownership and done long-term harm to the concept of ownership. The logic part is that we are talking about concepts which are clearly diametrically opposed, DRM and DRM-free. If I am currently unsatisfied at the amount of what I perceive as DRM, then what would satisfy me is to have a reduction in DRM. If someone else doesn't really care about DRM or not, then this helps maintain the status quo so I remain unsatisfied.
You are correct that other avenues may be more effective in raising awareness of DRM-free. I don't necessarily disagree and can admit I personally prefer the forum format and feel comfortable here compared to other such avenues. However, beyond my subjective preferences, I would also like to point out that it does makes some sense to stick together with others who share similar views versus what seems to me to be shouting into the void. Even the GOG reddit is (imo) nauseatingly in favor of Galaxy. This forum is a really rare resource of people who care about DRM-free. I think there is value in connecting with other users here, such as in this Boycotting topic itself.
As there is no absolute certainty, making some noise on the forum here could even turn out to be the right approach. Somewhat different example, but look at the failed Hitman Online Edition release here. It felt to me that staff suggested that the flood of negative reviews (here, on this site, granted not necessarily from the forum outrage) is what turned the tide, and which subsequently got covered in other bigger gaming media sties and channels. Who knows, maybe the boycott continues to gain traction to the point it gets Youtube coverage, where if I were to just post Youtube comments about DRM-free they would quickly be ignored/overtaken by other unrelated comments.