Undeadbeat: It's a separate game and does not directly affect the original games in any way, and without it the series would be dead and buried by now anyway - or, worse yet, there could have been another Brotherhood of Steel game in its place. Either way, being angry about Fallout 3 seems completely ridiculous to me.
razvan252: it does.
1. it started a shitty fps tradition for fallout games.
2. with that it killed the predecessors.
3. with that it shattered any hope of a real fallout game being made.
4. it used its predecessors name in the worst way.
5. its just bad.
bethesda didnt need the fallout license to create fallout 3. they could ave started a new game series.
Are you honestly saying that you cannot enjoy Fallout 1 and 2 simply due to Fallout 3 being the way it is? That Fallout 1 and 2 somehow became worse when Fallout 3 was released? Things don't work that way. Let me respond to your individual points.
1. First off, Fallout 3 isn't actually an FPS any more than Fallout 1 and 2 were turn-based combat simulators. And it really hasn't started any "tradition" at all, it's just one game. If several more Fallout games are released and play the same way, I might buy that part of your point, but that's several years into the future. You can't claim that a tradition of any kind has been started because one single game does something a particular way.
2. Did installing Fallout 3 on your computer remove Fallout 1 and 2 from it? Did it make the original games worse in some way? You really need to elaborate on this, because I can't wrap my head around how one game "kills" another. This does not happen.
3. What hope was there for another "real" Fallout game being made? Black Isle no longer produces anything, you know. How do you define a "real" Fallout game? Isometric and turn-based? I'm sorry to break this to you, but that just wouldn't work today. As much as I'd love to see another isometric, turn-based Fallout, the fact is that the only people who'd buy it are some of the ones who loved the original games. That's fine for a fan project that people make in their spare time, but any proper product has to bring in money to be viable.
4. No, Fallout: Brotherhood of Steel used the name "in the worst way". Have you played this game? If you haven't please do so. Go on, I'll wait. Once you're done, we'll see if you honestly believe that Fallout 3 is the worst thing to happen to Fallout.
5. If you don't like the game, don't play it. I'm pretty sure nobody's holding a gun to your head and forcing you.
Bethesda could have created their own post-nuclear role playing game franchise, that's true. They could not, however, have created Fallout 3 under that guise if they didn't want to get sued. I fail to see how buying a dead franchise and reviving it is doing anyone a disservice.