It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
avatar
phaolo: That's a better point than the Han Solo one.
But.. I doubt that many non-Jedi have been trained in sword-fighting* in a futuristic world where blasters are common.
For Jedi it makes sense, because with light sabers they can also deflect lasers.

* except for those new stormtroopers with the nonsensical melee weapons, however..
Well, blasters being common is no different than firearms being common, and still some people do train fencing, sword fighting and stuff like that, and police uses batons and soldiers carry knives. If anything, it makes more sense in the often technologicaly inconsistent Star Wars universe full of various strange cultures, often seemingly very anachronistic.
Post edited January 09, 2018 by Breja
downloading Force Unleashed while being throttled by my ISP. :P 10 hours in I'm half done. XD
avatar
Breja: Well, blasters being common is no different than firearms being common, and still some people do train fencing, sword fighting and stuff like that, and police uses batons and soldiers carry knives. If anything, it makes more sense in the often technologicaly inconsistent Star Wars universe full of various strange cultures, often seemingly very anachronistic.
Yeah, some people.. for sport.
I doubt soldiers are trained in sword fighting, more likely in knife and hand-to-hand combat, which is completely different.

In SW it could be plausible on poor planets with low technology, or some strange traditions.
But for common folks or imperial soldiers? Nah..
Post edited January 09, 2018 by phaolo
avatar
Breja: Well, blasters being common is no different than firearms being common, and still some people do train fencing, sword fighting and stuff like that, and police uses batons and soldiers carry knives. If anything, it makes more sense in the often technologicaly inconsistent Star Wars universe full of various strange cultures, often seemingly very anachronistic.
avatar
phaolo: Yeah, some people.. for sport.
I doubt soldiers are trained in sword fighting, more likely knife and hand-to-hand combat, which is completely different.
Like I said, different cultures, where it may well be far more common. In Star Trek Klingons love their Bat'leths, swords and other melee weapons, even though they have perfectly good disruptors. And yeah, no shit our real world military training is different than the Star Wars universe. I'm pretty sure that if fighting droids, Wookiees and people wielding laser swords was likely to happen, we'd train our soldiers different too :D
avatar
Breja: Like I said, different cultures, where it may well be far more common. In Star Trek Klingons love their Bat'leths, swords and other melee weapons, even though they have perfectly good disruptors. And yeah, no shit our real world military training is different than the Star Wars universe. I'm pretty sure that if fighting droids, Wookiees and people wielding laser swords was likely to happen, we'd train our soldiers different too :D
Ah, you replied too fast while I was editing my post.
Yes, in some cases it could make sense.
But it wouldn't be common.

Btw, I doubt I'd challenge a robot in a sword fight :P
And a wookie deserves a shot in the head ASAP. XD

And about light sabers: they're rare and made by Jedi.
With mind control, force chocke or push, any melee would be useless against them.
avatar
phaolo: And about light sabers: they're rare and made by Jedi.
With mind control, force chocke or push, any melee would be useless against them.
Soldiers are expendable for the empire, if they can just slow down a jedi until reinforcements arrive, that's easily worth it no matter how many the Jedi might chop to pieces in the process.

And yeah, lighsabers are rare, but not quite enough as not to be a threat. In the new novels there was a group of cultists post-Return of the Jedi who worshiped Vader and sought out lighsabres across the galaxy to use in an uprising againts the New Republic. And they weren't force users.
avatar
LootHunter: SW IS relativistic. The whole stars-become-lines mode point is to go FTL.
avatar
wpegg: It's not really worth drilling into (we've already established the series of films struggle with Newtonian physics), but Star Wars goes to "light speed", or in the case of The Falcon, "she can do point 5 past light speed". If you exceed light speed through conventional accelleration then you're breaking relativity. They also don't address any time related crazyness that would result from it all. I think it's safe to say they ignore relativity, rather than account for it.
By "relativistic" I just ment that in SW lightspeed exists as maximum speed in realspace. And in realspace all ships (in films at least) move with speeds much slower than speed of llight. So yes, SW doesn't deal with relativistic effects. When ships travel between planets and star systems they use hyperdrive the unconventional means to travel faster than light. You can look here for more details.
avatar
LootHunter: Legends
None of that's canon.
avatar
LootHunter: Legends
avatar
DaCostaBR: None of that's canon.
I don't care. Legends are Star Wars Expanded Universe, where people made (or at least tried) to explain the laws and lore of the Far Away Galaxy.

Disney's canon is a crap, lorewise.
avatar
LootHunter: I don't care. Legends are Star Wars Expanded Universe, where people made (or at least tried) to explain the laws and lore of the Far Away Galaxy.

Disney's canon is a crap, lorewise.
It's glorified fanfiction.
avatar
LootHunter: I don't care. Legends are Star Wars Expanded Universe, where people made (or at least tried) to explain the laws and lore of the Far Away Galaxy.

Disney's canon is a crap, lorewise.
avatar
DaCostaBR: It's glorified fanfiction.
You mean how Rian Johnson stole the plot for the whole movie from SW fanfiction?

http://scavengersholocron.com/category/home/something-you-should-know-about-the-last-jedi/

That should tell you why this movie is retarded.
All this fuckin controtversy about this movie, I have to see this shit. I missed out on the theatrical release.
I watched this film for the first time today, to say it was a pile of shit is offensive to shit. Political agenas, gravity in space, Rose, terrible acting, scenes stolen from Empire and Return. No thanks! I'm done.
I liked it.

Not as much as VII, but I liked it.

"And fuck the naysayers 'cause they don’t mean a thing
‘Cause this is what style we bring..."
Saw it a couple of days ago. Pretty much went eh in the end. Plot makes little sense to me and i feel that the casino scene should have been cut from the movie. Some nice special effects though .