My Dual Shock PS2 controller (using joytokey) doesn't work properly, hence this question. I have to plug it in after getting to the main menu of the game or the menu ring will spin around endlessly, and if I activate analogue in-game then the game acts as if the up direction is always being pressed.

I am a TR freak, love them all, even AOD, but if I had to use a controller to play it I'd never get through the Croft Manor Intro. :P

Keyboard for me until AOD, then I switch to Keyboard + Mouse.

I was initially thinking I'd do a twin stick kind of solution but considering the side step is crap and you can't look around while moving, maybe it's not worth it.