Posted May 16, 2015
Was wondering the differences between Red and Purple quests since Yarpen can choose either.
So I gathered some data. I worked on the side quests part.
First, there're the pie charts. They show the proportion of each type of side quests in all cards. That's more or less (not exactly true, since there can be two side quests of the same type on one card) what you're likely to get with each quest card draw.
If we compare red and purple, first we can see that red has a 12% of monster side quests. Obviously, red focuses more on combat, whereas purple focuses more on travel (+7%) and on gold (+3%).
Then, there's a shift too in the color. Red will give you more purple (+4%) side quests (those that are also used on 16 VP quests) and less red and blue side quests (-3% each).
So what to conclude? There's actually a very slight margin in the total leads side quests given (2%). The main difference is the focus on combat/travel.
But it's not enough to judge. We need to know what are the amounts of leads asked.
For that, there're the bar charts. The amount/card is the mean amount taking into account all 16 quest cards. So it's just the total leads asked divided by 16. There's a total bar but it's not very fair because it weighs gold the same way it does leads and the rate is not exactly 1:1.
Despite that, the main difference again comes from the nature of each color. Purple will ask more gold in average than red (1.13 vs. 0.75). In a 3 quests game, it's roughly a 1.2 difference. Not much, I agree!
The average lead amount is almost similar.
More interesting is the average amount asked, when the specific lead is asked. Red quests almost always ask 3 leads for each color. Now, the rate for 3 leads side quests (4/3) is less good than the one for 2 leads side quests (3/2). And purple quests are in average closer to that 2 than red, if we exclude gold, except for purple leads. As an aside, I think it's a good thing because I find purple leads extremely easy to gather for Dandelion.
Conclusion? Again, not major differences. So, what other criteria to use?
Well, there'a a last chart that shows the average amount of leads asked by each quest. There it's pretty obvious that purple quests will ask more purple leads, some gold (the one 13 gold quest) and red quests more red leads.
So, in that matter the choice mainly depends on your investigation preference. What color do you prefer investigating?
Finally, there's another consideration: the quest rewards. Red will give you a bit more fortune cards in average, but less development (0.13 each). Purple will additionaly grant investigation cards, especially purple ones (0.25). Now, the main difference is that red will create more monsters in average.
Also, keep in mind that almost all red quests (3/4) will trigger combat when completed. All in all, you'll fight a lot more with red, which means you'll need to use your weapons more, thus spend more turns using command.
I say it's pretty balanced and there's no real bad choice. I'd have to compare purple and red investigation cards to be set on that matter.
So I gathered some data. I worked on the side quests part.
First, there're the pie charts. They show the proportion of each type of side quests in all cards. That's more or less (not exactly true, since there can be two side quests of the same type on one card) what you're likely to get with each quest card draw.
If we compare red and purple, first we can see that red has a 12% of monster side quests. Obviously, red focuses more on combat, whereas purple focuses more on travel (+7%) and on gold (+3%).
Then, there's a shift too in the color. Red will give you more purple (+4%) side quests (those that are also used on 16 VP quests) and less red and blue side quests (-3% each).
So what to conclude? There's actually a very slight margin in the total leads side quests given (2%). The main difference is the focus on combat/travel.
But it's not enough to judge. We need to know what are the amounts of leads asked.
For that, there're the bar charts. The amount/card is the mean amount taking into account all 16 quest cards. So it's just the total leads asked divided by 16. There's a total bar but it's not very fair because it weighs gold the same way it does leads and the rate is not exactly 1:1.
Despite that, the main difference again comes from the nature of each color. Purple will ask more gold in average than red (1.13 vs. 0.75). In a 3 quests game, it's roughly a 1.2 difference. Not much, I agree!
The average lead amount is almost similar.
More interesting is the average amount asked, when the specific lead is asked. Red quests almost always ask 3 leads for each color. Now, the rate for 3 leads side quests (4/3) is less good than the one for 2 leads side quests (3/2). And purple quests are in average closer to that 2 than red, if we exclude gold, except for purple leads. As an aside, I think it's a good thing because I find purple leads extremely easy to gather for Dandelion.
Conclusion? Again, not major differences. So, what other criteria to use?
Well, there'a a last chart that shows the average amount of leads asked by each quest. There it's pretty obvious that purple quests will ask more purple leads, some gold (the one 13 gold quest) and red quests more red leads.
So, in that matter the choice mainly depends on your investigation preference. What color do you prefer investigating?
Finally, there's another consideration: the quest rewards. Red will give you a bit more fortune cards in average, but less development (0.13 each). Purple will additionaly grant investigation cards, especially purple ones (0.25). Now, the main difference is that red will create more monsters in average.
Also, keep in mind that almost all red quests (3/4) will trigger combat when completed. All in all, you'll fight a lot more with red, which means you'll need to use your weapons more, thus spend more turns using command.
I say it's pretty balanced and there's no real bad choice. I'd have to compare purple and red investigation cards to be set on that matter.
Attachments:
pie_chart_red.png (19 Kb)
pie_chart_purple.png (18 Kb)
graph_red.png (23 Kb)
graph_purple.png (25 Kb)
bar_chart_quest.png (19 Kb)