It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
I finished this excellent expansion a few minutes ago and I was curious what people thought about the mysterious character, Gaunter O'Dimm.

At first, while I thought he was interesting, he was somewhat cliché, like a typical devil with penaché for lawyering up, but then I was thinking about a theory that made him a little different.

He called himself a merchant and when Geralt said he was obviously not human, he didn't object possibly indicating he might have been. The professor found evidence of a so called Evil Incarnate as old as thousands of years appearing in multiple forms in different cultures. The last bit when you defeat him in the riddle world, he begins to talk in Elder Speech which finalized my theory:
He could possibly have been an elf long ago, most likely a merchant, Sage or both then finding an ancient secret or power that made him what he is. The whole speech about being a master of mirrors might indicate he had a certain interest in them when he was actually a living being, I find it strange that a demon that enjoys mischief would have a personal interest in them in a natural way.

After I had finished the expansion I looked up what happened if you don't try to beat his riddle and there was a small mention about him giving you advice about Ciri, he specifically said that even his powers were beyond her help. That was very interesting, I really liked that bit because that somewhat proves he is not all powerful like a diety yet he knew the threat she was facing.

Two other things I really enjoyed was the talking pets (specifically of how calm and seemingly intelligent they appeared to be, being well aware of O'Dimm) and the Ofieri merchants.

All in all, a superb expansion bringing an inconsequential character from the beginning to life that I had almost forgotten (although at the time I had my suspicions that he might be important later, one of the earlier moments I realized this game would be something special).
I never took him for an elf, even for a moment. My view was that he is some form of post conjunction being, albeit much more powerful than most of the 'creatures' that came through. Remember that humans came through the cataclysm, too, and those human 'ancestors' "learned how to harness the power of primordial Chaos, and thus the first human wizards were born." [Witcher glossary]
avatar
Nirth: I finished this excellent expansion a few minutes ago and I was curious what people thought about the mysterious character, Gaunter O'Dimm.
You are missing some cultural context, our (post-USSR slavic) devil is based on "The Master and Margarita", written by Mikhail Bulgakov. It is mandatory book for many school education programs, everyone knows him. Definitely worth a read.

Our devil isn't a lawyering genie by Hollywood, it's closer to Mephistopheles in Goethe

Ein Teil von jener Kraft,
Die stets das Böse will
Und stets das Gute schafft.

/I'm part of the force, which wants evil and does good.(Used as epigraph to M&M).

O'Dimm for me was a strong homage to this book.

Olgerd and his band - Ukraine. Clothes, haircut, weapon, giant pig as coat of arms, savage behavior, (plus, if we bring politics, they regularly sign deals with devil...)
I have always seen the whole "merchant of mirrors" as completely symbolic. He is probably some kind of ancient demon (at least that seems to be implied) who has always been preying on people's desires in order to collect souls. The "merchant of mirrors" name I think is partly due to the fact that people tasks are always a product of - or specifically a reflection of - their own desires. At the same time accepting his tasks forces individuals to consider who they truly are; i.e. to look at their own reflection.

I also agree with the Goethe-reference comment. The "pact with the devil" theme is very clear.
avatar
Hickory: My view was that he is some form of post conjunction being, albeit much more powerful than most of the 'creatures' that came through.
You're probably right, the professor did mention that the only thing he truly values is human souls but frankly, it seemed more like an amusement, it just happens to be his deal (profession, how he feeds his own sense of hunger). You could see how Olgierd lost his touch of it what it means to be human yet O'Dimm, seemingly immortal, had a sense of humour and a thrill to watch others, most likely because his abilities were purely in his nature whereas we were never meant to expand our life span too much. This doesn't necessarily clash with my theory though as I think if he was an elf or a mage from long time ago and merged with some ancient power, it's possible this power in itself was somewhat alive, not changing his nature, merely giving him different abilities as long as he has it.

There's an interesting reference to Lost with this. There's a character there that becomes changed after a certain event that reflects partially to what O'Dimm represents. This entity that assimilates with the character, we never get to see if it's alive or even if it's part of the natural world but once its fusion with the human, something else was <span class="bold">created</span>.
avatar
Gremlion: You are missing some cultural context, our (post-USSR slavic) devil is based on "The Master and Margarita", written by Mikhail Bulgakov. It is mandatory book for many school education programs, everyone knows him. Definitely worth a read.
I haven't read the book but my dad mentioned it as his favourite when it comes to the Russian classics, I'll likely read it in the future.
avatar
Gremlion: Our devil isn't a lawyering genie by Hollywood, it's closer to Mephistopheles in Goethe

Ein Teil von jener Kraft,
Die stets das Böse will
Und stets das Gute schafft.

/I'm part of the force, which wants evil and does good.(Used as epigraph to M&M).

O'Dimm for me was a strong homage to this book.
I haven't read Faust but I'm familiar with it. I did some googling after finishing the game and I came upon a similar but polish folklore legend, Pan Twardowski. It's likely a direct inspiration for the developers as it says that the sorcerer who makes the deal with the devil gets a tragic end unlike Faust.
avatar
Jespersgaard: I have always seen the whole "merchant of mirrors" as completely symbolic. He is probably some kind of ancient demon (at least that seems to be implied) who has always been preying on people's desires in order to collect souls. The "merchant of mirrors" name I think is partly due to the fact that people tasks are always a product of - or specifically a reflection of - their own desires. At the same time accepting his tasks forces individuals to consider who they truly are; i.e. to look at their own reflection.
I can't believe I missed that even at the end when (if) you play his riddle game and finds him in the water. Thanks for bringing that up.

I tried to find the exact advice he gives regarding Ciri but I couldn't, anyone knows where I can find it?
Look at 3:20 for his Ciri advice. (MAJOR SPOILERS obviously)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j3oGWhfVku4
avatar
Jespersgaard: Look at 3:20 for his Ciri advice. (MAJOR SPOILERS obviously)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j3oGWhfVku4
Thank you. That will be useful for my next playthrough, really didn't like the ending I got.