I really love this game so much.. The story is just amazing, the setting and atmosphere is even more amazing.. Hell, I know a lot of people hate it, but I even loved the combat.

To anyone thinking about buying this I really recommend you to do so, you won't be disappointed.

Despite some people, I love combat system, as well. It wasn't perfect, but it had its own goods on it.
As for game itself, yeah, it is must-play for most RPG lovers. It has one of the best stories, which late RPGs forgot to develop...

I just loved everything, I find it so inspired in every aspect.
I wonder why people complain about the combat, I found it to be very engaging and immersive, and fun. Plus, the animations gave it a great feel, imo.
With the FCR mod I gets even better, so real, just like in the books.

I read a few books and tried to play the game for years, buy the limited edition and so but never could play. Just started and the combat feels strange. I'll keep playing and I'll finish the game because I've three copies right now.