It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
Community
The WitcherNeutrality(11 posts)solved(11 posts)solved
(11 posts)solved
Pages:
1
This is my favourite topic
Posted June 30, 2011
So it was possible to do things with neutrality.. I couldn't walk away from everything. But it was possible?
This question / problem has been solved by scollins1987image
Posted June 30, 2011
avatar
Antimateria: So it was possible to do things with neutrality.. I couldn't walk away from everything. But it was possible?
The only quest where there is no neutral choice is "Gold Rush", the bank robbery. You must also persuade one of the aligned parties (Yaevinn or Siegfried) to stand with you in "The Unforgiven", at the end of Act III. But you can regain your neutrality later.

(You could say that you have no neutral choice between Triss and Shani, but that has no such significant consequences.)
Posted June 30, 2011
avatar
Antimateria: So it was possible to do things with neutrality.. I couldn't walk away from everything. But it was possible?
avatar
cjrgreen: The only quest where there is no neutral choice is "Gold Rush", the bank robbery. You must also persuade one of the aligned parties (Yaevinn or Siegfried) to stand with you in "The Unforgiven", at the end of Act III. But you can regain your neutrality later.

(You could say that you have no neutral choice between Triss and Shani, but that has no such significant consequences.)
i aligned with elves. Those fucking humans.. =) But that game.. it was lets say, there was not right or wrong.
Posted June 30, 2011
avatar
cjrgreen: (You could say that you have no neutral choice between Triss and Shani, but that has no such significant consequences.)
MINOR SPOILERS:


You have to pick whether to give Alvin to Triss or Shani, but I don't think you actually need to get romantically involved with either of them if you don't want to. You have to specifically give a gift if you want to start a serious relationship. I haven't tried not giving the gift though, anyone know how much is changed if you do that?
Posted July 01, 2011
one of them will behave in a very cold way afterwards.
Other then some artwork you don't miss out a lot
Posted July 01, 2011
avatar
CyPhErIoN: one of them will behave in a very cold way afterwards.
Other then some artwork you don't miss out a lot
I believe that some shops are also unavailable (the merchants choose not to sell to you because of your reputation after the choice).
Posted July 01, 2011
avatar
Ebon-Hawk: I believe that some shops are also unavailable (the merchants choose not to sell to you because of your reputation after the choice).
yes but it doesn't mae a difference.
This isn't a result of chosing shani or triss
its a result from other choices.
Anyway its not difficult.
Its either the order armorer or the dwarve blacksmith
Posted July 01, 2011
avatar
CyPhErIoN: Its either the order armorer or the dwarve blacksmith
Or Kalkstein, if you choose the neutral path.
Posted July 09, 2011
Some choices in the game (i.e. Triss vs. Shani) really have little to do with Geralt's factional neutrality, although they are no less interesting with respect to plot and some rather important story consequences.

However, for the factional conflicts:

In "Force Recon", one remains neutral by refusing to lead the Order assault against the elves. However, I received no negative consequences for completing this mission and was still able to be neutral later. During "Gold Rush", you have to choose sides to eliminate the possibility of helping one side in the "Free Elves" quest. If you help, say, the elves, in "Gold Rush" you have the option of helping the elves or remaining neutral in "Free Elves". Same thing if you choose to help the Order in "Gold Rush": you can help the Order or remain neutral in "Free Elves".

Inevitably, only "Free Elves" is the mission where you decide to be neutral or not, although if you are planning to side with the Order or with Yaevin, you have to choose their sides during "Gold Rush".
Post edited July 09, 2011 by scollins1987
Posted July 10, 2011
Well, these answers clears much. So thanks.
In chapter two..


SPOILER WARNING!!




Was it possible that I could find someone else quilty than the detective?




Edit: Can't really put my finger on it did I ask that already at somepoint. Anyway.. I'll put this finally in "solved"-state.. =)
Post edited July 10, 2011 by Antimateria
Posted July 10, 2011
SPOILER WARNING:



avatar
Antimateria: Was it possible that I could find someone else quilty than the detective?
It is possible to come up with the wrong suspect during the investigation, but you will learn that Raymond is responsible at the end of the chapter regardless. Full details on the possibilities in the "Vizima Confidential" quest are here:

http://witcher.wikia.com/wiki/Vizima_Confidential
Pages:
1
This is my favourite topic
Community
The WitcherNeutrality(11 posts)solved(11 posts)solved
(11 posts)solved