I can't enable the second player even though my controller is properly recognized. I have seen screenshots online that it's supposed to show an option at the bottom of the ESC menu that lets you hit tab to enable the second player but it's not showing up for me. The game lets me use the controller for the main player and changes all the buttom prompts etc. so it should be working.

I have tried restarting the game and the save file, changing the difficulty, launching through steam, but it doesn't seem to work.