dcthenew52: Hi. I have a question.

I thought I could get both Fragarach and Scather, by

1. rescue Thrommel

2. then kill him

3. and take Fragarach from him and hide in a chest or something

4. and raise him from dead (I usually go to Jaroo the Druid)

5. and few days later some people appear and give me Scather.

That's what I've done like, a year ago.

Now, when I take Fragarach and hide it until Thromme's people reward me, they don't give me Scather.

Is this only happens to me? Or did the devs of mods fixed it cuz they thought it's a bug?

BTW, I'm currently installed and play with Co8 and Temple Plus mod.

osm: as the game is insanely bugged it's still continually patched by the T+ project

that said, this time around you might be playing with a diff aligned party - I suspect they do the full reward only for the good-aligned (or maybe chaotic) one.
User Cattletech here can advise better tho (or you could ask on rpgcodex).