Hope someone can help. I've never actually "played" the Haedeko puppet game in the City of Souls because my avatar has always been maxed out at that point (50th level). But I wanted to try it recently and noticed that I did not have the Mentor puppet. Can anyone tell me which map has this puppet (and which monster drops it)? Thanks!

Well , there's not a fixed one but i used the claw of pick pocketry in the city.
I got mine from there wondering why the hell i would ever need it :)

The doubles can just be sold :)
you need the hero , mage , shadow , jester , archmage and guardian
in the clockwork crypt i found a few hadeko dolls.
Try to have a look there if you passed it i think you might have forgotten some parts.