The game starts up just fine but nothing I press on the controller does anything. I have tried plugging it into different ports, as well as plugging it in after starting the game and nothing does the trick. Any thoughts? I'm running Windows 10.

EDIT: Nevermind. Apparently this is one of those older games that doesn't like there being multiple gamepads plugged in and apparently the other gamepad (on my G13 keyboard thing) that I don't use that functionality of it apparently got un-disabled.