Posted February 17, 2009
I will give the makers of Runaway a certain level of props for trying. They didn't go the clickable slideshow route of the umpteen thousand Myst-clones that pass for the majority of the modern adventure game market. (These are not universally awful, of course, but they tend to lack a certain something.) And it's certainly a good looking game, with smooth, cartoony visuals that bring back memories of the good old days...except with modern rendering power.
Unfortunately, they flub the single most important aspect of the genre, to my tastes - the writing. If the writing isn't good - oneliners, plot, dialogue, whatever else - I really feel you may as well not bother. It's not that I dislike puzzles, but there are many pure puzzlers out there that tend to scratch that particular itch better than the adventure genre. It's the bundling of puzzling and engaging storytelling that make adventure games magic to me. And Runaway has incredibly terrible writing, across the board. The "humor" is forced and moronic. The plot is a mishmash of cliches and boredom. The characters are extremely grating and obnoxious. And if I recall correctly, it's translated from French and poorly. (Maybe it's better in French, but I doubt it.)
So right there, Runaway drops off the "worth playing" list to my mind. It then compounds that sin by having dumb and unintuitive "puzzling" barely worthy of the name. Trust me. Go buy the Broken Sword games instead. -They- offer the sort of adventure gaming experience that made the genre great.
Unfortunately, they flub the single most important aspect of the genre, to my tastes - the writing. If the writing isn't good - oneliners, plot, dialogue, whatever else - I really feel you may as well not bother. It's not that I dislike puzzles, but there are many pure puzzlers out there that tend to scratch that particular itch better than the adventure genre. It's the bundling of puzzling and engaging storytelling that make adventure games magic to me. And Runaway has incredibly terrible writing, across the board. The "humor" is forced and moronic. The plot is a mishmash of cliches and boredom. The characters are extremely grating and obnoxious. And if I recall correctly, it's translated from French and poorly. (Maybe it's better in French, but I doubt it.)
So right there, Runaway drops off the "worth playing" list to my mind. It then compounds that sin by having dumb and unintuitive "puzzling" barely worthy of the name. Trust me. Go buy the Broken Sword games instead. -They- offer the sort of adventure gaming experience that made the genre great.