So I've been playing the game with an Xbox 360 controller and it usually runs fine (except sometimes select is R3 and Start is RT). But when I plug in the 2nd Xbox 360 controller, the game messes up the control scheme to the point that the first controller doesn't work and only the 2nd controller works. I tried to change the inputs for them but it either doesn't work or Player 1 and Player 2 are controlled by 1 controller.

Wondering if anyone found any solution for this?

I have two xbox controllers plugged in as well, one controller registers as both players 1 and 2 while the other controller does nothing. Very frustrating.