fahbs: Yeah your only hope of taking out major power capitals is the first turn you're adjacent to it (land wise
or amphibious landing wise). You have a chance of winning the offensive battle and then
surviving the rush of reinforcements that arrive after. If you wait even one turn then forget
it.
My most recent game I literally eliminated every aspect of a major power except for his capital.
Home regions, conquered regions, colonies, merchant fleet, all conquered and reduced to
nothing. But he was still able to maintain 30 heavy artillery in his capital and it was
literally impossible to touch him. I tried 3 separate attacks with max units: one of all light
artillery, one of all infantry + combat engineer, and one all cavalry + combat engineer. None
of the attacks had even one unit make it to firing range. Literally impossible to win.
The diplomacy is definitely frustrating. Major powers will never ever accept peace until they
become so weak that it's easier to just conquer and finish them off. Would like for them to have
the ability to realize when wars are just pointless stalemates and end them.
It's possible to take out those Verduns if you are willing to commit the resources and manpower needed. This of course is based on the assumption you are so strong as to be able to raise large numbers of manpower [if you can recruit 20 or 30 or more workers to the city per turn] and that you are not heavily committed elsewhere. It also depends on how much you really want that city. If you have him boxed up, all you need to do is keep an army next to him and he will never stick out his neck. Assuming of course you have already obliterated his navy and merchantmen.
To take a massively fortified city I build lots [and I do mean lots] of scouts and light artillery. You will need a lot because you will lose a lot. I use one or two engineers to knock down the walls. I make a line of scouts and rush them forward. They get wiped out but they draw fire. Next, you rush your light arty forward and hit his heavy arty. Don't simply wear them down, as they will rest up and come back to full power later. Kill as many as possible. Once dead, he cannot rebuild them. You will have to repeat this process several times, but if you have the resources and willingness to use them, you will prevail.
Sometimes the computer will make a tactical error in setting up the fort's defense. He may have lots of heavy arty, but leave them off screen and pile up lots of mobile artillery in the front line. To cope with this, I line up my heavy arty but leave one row of dots empty. This will encourage him to move his light arty up. On my turn, I move my heavy arty forward a row and the next turn I wipe out his light arty. Then I can use my own artillery, light and heavy, to wipe out the rest of his army.
Often, though, I would prefer to wait until a tech progression. Just make sure to leave enough spare arms builds so you can upgrade all or much of your key units.