This post intrigued me, so I went out and did
a bit of research. ;-)
Arkose: Existing cloud office suites are no competition. While the Starter versions have some advanced functionality removed they still have more features than Google Docs or the like.
More features does not equal no competition. But actually, Google Docs
does have features unavailable in the free version of Office 2010 such as table of contents, equation editing, footnotes(!), annotations, a drawing tool (which makes sense, because Word uses PowerPoint integration for that, iirc), and bookmarks. I may be missing a few of them.
(I wasn’t sure whether to include document translation in that list. Office sort of has this? It literally just copies and pastes the document into microsofttranslator.com; it’s a really lazy "implementation", and there’s no way to get the translated document back together except with manual copy and paste. It looks like it’ll break things in documents with complicated formatting.)
Arkose: Starter also includes the ability to copy the programs and documents onto a USB flash drive so you can take it with you and use it on the go.
This has been an option with all the office software I mentioned for
years.
Arkose: OpenOffice is a nice idea, but it lacks the compatibility and functionality of the real thing.
“The real thing”? Microsoft Office is A, not THE, office suite. There have been more popular suites before it, and there will be more popular suites after it. OpenOffice.org compatibility is actually pretty decent with Microsoft Office (I haven’t had issues with your average Word document for several years), and it’s got a heckuva lot more functionality than this Office Starter thing.
Arkose: The online apps have seemingly all the functionality of the desktop versions
No they don’t, not even close. That really doesn’t look like very many features at all to me. Unless it’s going to dramatically improve by release? Although “beta” implies that it’s feature complete, and the Microsoft apps I’ve seen in beta haven’t gained many features before they released.
Arkose: Synching a document to and from the web is done at the touch of a button, and this also allows you to load web files into the desktop version and edit them directly rather than having to save a local copy and then re-upload the new version.
That is nice. Although, it’s not an issue with Google Docs or AbiWord, the latter of which actually allows you to edit the document collaboratively without switching to a web-based interface (there is no web-browser editing or one-click export to Google Docs though, which is admittedly rather lame). I use Dropbox for my insta-sync fix.
Additionally, the Microsoft Office implementation of this in the beta is highly flawed; to sync seamlessly with SkyDrive, you seem to have to save documents in a specific system-selected folder. On my system the folder path was “C:\Users\James\AppData\Roaming\NVD\{20140066-0066-0409-0000-0000000FF1CE}”. This location isn't even added to the Windows 7 documents library. Good luck copying your document onto a flash drive. :-P
Arkose: Apps may have a free option as well, and even if there is some fee involved it's certainly an attractive option for some purposes.
So, wait. Existing office suites are no competition, but you’re not even sure if Office 2010 cloud (which competes head to head with free services) is free?
I’m not saying that Office 2010 Starter might not be great. I’m saying it’s not as great as you think it is.