Unless I'm wrong, we'd be at:

Advent Rising - Catshade
Age of Wonders - grounddown77
Alien Shooter 2: Reloaded - SladeStrife
Alone in the Dark New Nightmare - Cassidy
Amerzone: The Explorer Legacy - psicat
Another World: 15th Anniversary edition - Taleroth
Arcanum: Of Steamworks and Magick Obscura - Sh4d3s
Arx Fatalis - keeveek
Baldur's Gate: The Original Saga - Shadowdragoon
Battle Isle Platinum - Lexor
Betrayal at Krondor Pack - SpirlaStairs
Blood (One unit whole blood) - hucklebarry
Bloodrayne - CowboyBebop
Beyond Divinity - Phosphenes
Beyond Good and Evil - Zchinque
Call to Power 2 - tikeno
Capitalism 2 - wolfsnake
Combat Mission: Beyond Overlord - Mamutte
Commandos 2+3 - Snizzle012
Constructor - cheesetruncheon
Creatures exoudos - qazx
Dark Reign + Expansion - wlmiv
Desperados: Wanted Dead or Alive - csmith
Evil Genius - Racan
Feeble Files, The - Austrobogulator
Flatout - HomerSimpson
Forgotten Realms: Demon Stone - Garugo
Gabriel Knight: Sins of the Fathers - GoJays2025
Ghost Master - bsu
Gorky 17 - tburger
Gothic - SLP2000
Heagemonia Gold Edition - Bodkin
Heritage of Kings: The Settlers - saramakos
Heroes of Might and Magic 2: Gold edition - icepowdah
Icewind Dale Complete - ChaunceyK
Jack Orlando: A cinematic adventure (DC) - FearItself
Jagged Alliance - oasis789
Kingpin: Life of crime - habit79
Last Express, The - nmillar
Longest Journey, The - swizzle66
Lords of Magic: Special edition - Vitalfever
Master of Orion 1+2 - Xibalba
Messiah - Kabuto
Might and Magic 6-Pack: Limited Edition - hobbes543
Might and Magic 7: For Blood and Honor - tarangwydion
Might and magic 8: Day of the destroyer - kodeen
Motor Racer - v1989
Neverwinter Nights: Diamond edition - Fantasysci5
Outcast - Detlik
Patrician 1+2 - Fujek
Phantasmagoria - Aningan
Police Quest 1+2+3+4 - CymTyr
Psychonauts - Delixe
Realms of the Haunting - grviper
Red Baron Pack - Rodzaju
Return to Krondor - Vitek
Runaway: A road adventure - Thiev
Shadowgrounds - adambiser
Sniper Elite: Berlin 1945 - taczillabr
Soldiers: Heroes of World War II - Ric1987
Space Rangers - Dragobr
Star Control 1+2 - Zolgar
Star Wolves - gyokzoli
Still Life - cosminm
Stronghold - MobiusArcher
Syberia 2 - cnquist
Temple Of Elemental Evil, The - sheva78
Total Annihilation: Commander pack - Rhineland
Tropico Reloaded - Hesusio
Two Worlds - park_84
Unreal Tournament GOTY - Titanium
Vampire The Masquerade - Redemption - lugum
XIII - deshadow52
Zork Anthology, The - Gilou

Creatures exoudos

Amerzone.

Oh sorry, I forgot that there are two games titled with Total Annihilation. I thought about Total Annihilation Commander Pack.

psicat already has Amerzone: The Explorer Legacy reserved as you could see in the list two mere postings above yours :p

Sorry I was used to the first list. in contest.
My guess goes to Motor Racer.

It is quite unlikely... but I guess I stay with my choice up there.

if they change there guess i would love mine to be unreal tournament GOTY but if not i will leave mine as alien shooter 2

Yeah, I'll just stick with my entry if that's not already assumed.

Assuming this is continuing to tomorrow, I'll stick with Tropico.

Hmm... I've noticed that all the Gems were $5.99 games. So I'm not sure if I made a valid choice.

EDIT: Whoops, Unreal Gold is $9.99. My mistake.

Haegemonia.

Heagemonia Gold Edition was already taken by Bodkin.
You might want to choose another title.

Imperial Glory

Eh, the good guesses were long since taken. Heh.

Okay then, Postal.