Posted October 31, 2008
tBOBXerxes: The difference with SDC is that you do not need to be online. You only need to verify your files one time (when you first install/buy your game) and after that you can play your games anytime, offline.
you don't even have to do that. if you have a retail box copy, you can install and play without registering online. you do have to register in order to access patches, updates, and new content for free. only games downloaded from impulse require you to register beforehand, because you need to in order to download the files.
regarding wardell's comment about the lawsuit, i agree with others here that the lawsuit is perfectly valid. EA did not disclose the presence of secuROM to the public at large, which is blatatnly anti-consumer. it may even run afoul of consumer protection laws. we'll have to see what the courts decide.
Cliftor: If I could "buy" a fancy piece of paper that specifically said "The undersigned is hereby granted a non-exclusive, lifetime license to use my software as he sees fight in perpetuity forever and ever amen after he gives me $50," with my signature and the IP holders signature, something that will last and be respected forever with the force of law behind it, sure, why not?
you can -- its called a a receipt. that transaction is a form of contract between the buyer and seller. within that transaction are your first-sale and fair-use rights -- which includes the ability to do what you want with the product without making additional copies (beyond copies for backup and personal, non-commercial use) of the content. software companies have been trying to change this for decades by calling sales "licenses" rather than sales. and courts have decides that simply calling a sale a "license" doesn't make it one.
i'd say that the law isn't clear on this because the nature of digital content means that existing copyright laws don't perfectly cover what people can do -- digital content essentially removes the physical limitations of analog content that copyright law relies upon to prevent unwarranted copying of content.
Post edited October 31, 2008 by illegalyouth