How about declaring things like "At this rate, you have two more weeks to vote" and "Do what you can to put your favourite games in the Hall of Fame by voting!" every day? :-) Officially, that's not bumping, as it contains (new) information or has its own function.

Yeah, I'll have to keep finding ways of keeping it afloat. So long as the votes keep coming in.

Hmph. It seems this thread is not that popular... I wonder why that is, when it is a good initiative. Oh, well.

1. Best Script
Fallout 2
2. Best Gameplay
Heroes of Might and magic III
3. Most innovative
Gothic
4. Best Graphics – Technical
Freespace 2
5. Best Graphics – Creative
The longest Journey
6. Best Sound
Duke Nukem 3D
7. Best Soundtrack
Heroes of Might and Magic II
10. Game of the Year
Might and Magic 6-pack
11. Best Action Game
MDK
12. Best Adventure Game
The longest Journey
13. Best Racing Game
Screamer
14. Best RPG Game
Fallout 2
15. Best Shooter Game
Duke Nukem 3D
16. Best Simulation Game
Freespace 2
18. Best Strategy Game
Heroes of Might and Magic III

One more attempt to bump this... Hope some readers will make use of their possibility to vote for their favorite GOG games. It'd be neat if this caught on...

1. Best Script
Raaaahhhh - tough one.
Gothic
2. Best Gameplay
Freespace 2
3. Most innovative
Original War
From what I have heard, Messiah could have qualified, but never played it, so...
4. Best Graphics – Technical
Far Cry
5. Best Graphics – Creative
Painkiller
10. Game of the Year
FreeSpace 2
11. Best Action Game
Far Cry
14. Best RPG Game
Arx Fatalis
15. Best Shooter Game
Far Cry
16. Best Simulation Game
FreeSpace 2
(Comanche vs Hokum does not get enough love though, IMO)
18. Best Strategy Game
Jagged Alliance 2
Too many categories. Next time, limit it so say 4 (Script - Innovation - Graphics - 3 Best Overall in order). I did not answer the first time I saw the thread because it was too massive.

You can always answer only those categories you see fit; you can even name only one or two nominees and leave all the other categories blank.
Anyway, thanks for you input (both for your nominations and for answering my question).

1. Best Script
Fallou... no wait... Psychonauts. I actually cared about the people!
2. Best Gameplay
Earth Worm Jim. Classic and easy.
3. Most innovative
Psychonauts.
4. Best Graphics – Technical
Dont care.
5. Best Graphics – Creative
Psychonauts, amazing and creative.
6. Best Sound
Psychonauts, gotta love Zim.
7. Best Soundtrack
Beyond Good and Evil.
8. Best Developer
Tim 'friggin' Schafer!
9. Best Publisher
Interplay.
10. Game of the Year
Arx Fatalis (best surprise of the year).
11. Best Action Game
Psychonauts (?)
12. Best Adventure Game
Broken sword.
13. Best Racing Game
14. Best RPG Game
Fallout 2.
15. Best Shooter Game
The Duke.
16. Best Simulation Game
Freespace 2.
17. Best Sports Game
18. Best Strategy Game
Empire Earth.
19. Best GOG User
Aliasalpha, always there and available :P
I really love Psychonauts if you can't tell.

1. Best Script
Beyond Good and Evil
too bad, it's a stub. can't wait for the sequel!
2. Best Gameplay
Painkiller
3. Most innovative
Giants - Citizen Kabuto
4. Best Graphics – Technical
Painkiller
still a feast for the eye
5. Best Graphics – Creative
Very, very though question.
Psychonauts looks amazingly original,
Beyond Good and Evil looks lovely, finally a world I'd really like to save,
Sacrifice is so weird it's mesmerizing,
and the pixel art in Ishar makes the game both cozy and exotic.
6. Best Sound
7. Best Soundtrack
Descent 3
crystal clear, beautiful, varied.
8. Best Developer
Thats a though one.
Shiny Entertainment, because they are creative and professional,
and
Attic, because they are badasses!
9. Best Publisher
Interplay
10. Game of the Year
Beyond Good and Evil
11. Best Action Game
Painkiller GOLD edition
12. Best Adventure Game
Sanitarium
13. Best Racing Game
14. Best RPG Game
I'll go with Fallout. The first
15. Best Shooter Game
Again, Painkiller
16. Best Simulation Game
Freespace 2
17. Best Sports Game
18. Best Strategy Game
Heroes of Might and Magic 3
19. Best GOG User

1. Best Script-Fallout (If for nothing else than the astounding ending. Although dialogue when playing a stupid character always makes me laugh.)
2. Best Gameplay-Fallout (Turn based combat at its finest.)
5. Best Graphics (Creative)-Psychonauts (Such a oddly unique design to everything in the world.)
6. Best Sound-Myst (The sound design alone creeps me out in this game.)
7. Best Soundtrack-Myst (One of my favorite video game soundtracks. Sets the mood perfectly to this excellent game.)
8. Best Developer-Cyan Worlds (The Myst series is the reason why I play games at all anymore. I'd probably be doing something productive right now like writing a novel.)
9. Best Publisher-Interplay (Not only do they have one of the bigger offerings, they also have some of the greatest games of all time in their catalog.)
10. Game of the Year-Fallout (It's my favorite game of all time and I'm glad that GOG has it.)

Closing date is now Dec 31st.
Winners will be announced Jan 3rd(ish)

The results are now in!